.com.unity Forums - Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

.com.unity Forums (http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/index.php)

- Space Empires: IV & V (http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/forumdisplay.php?f=20)

- - Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good?? (http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/showthread.php?t=8119)

Re: Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

no, System Wars does not have a website. It is, to my knowledge, an SE-based RTS game in a single system within the SE Universe......

and MOO3 has the one feature that I hate most about SE4: SIMULTANEOUS MOVEMENT. I hate and despise it, it's like a compromise between turn based and RTS. If you want TBS, play TBS, if you want RTS, play RTS but SM is just stupid.

Re: Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

I think that SE: System Wars has been put on hold.

Re: Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

Any idea when MOO3 will come out? Last time I looked in PC Gamer magazine, they said the game had already been released, yet I still don't see it in the stores.

Re: Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

First, here's a preview:
http://gamespot.com/gamespot/stories...902095,00.html

About those feature cuts....do you realise how that most of these features aren't even in SE4, and that most also aren't even worth it.

Quote:

-Customizing Your Empire's Color
-Customizing Your Ship's Look
-Customizing Your Homeworld's Name
-Customizing Each Star's Name You Conquer
-Seeing Pretty Stars On The Galaxy Map
-Bombs taken out???
-Not Able To Capture/Board Enemy Ships

Only 2 of those have real gameplay value, there are pleny of other things in MOO3 that aren't in SE4.

Even with all those features cut, there is plenty of game left to play. I think you should look at what is IN the game, not out, because then you could just as well say the SE4 sucks.

You have to keep in mind that MOO3 started as an ambitious project, by MOO fans. So off course, just like on this forum, you'll have a lot of ideas at, all meant to make a better game. QS has done a good job trying to incorporate most of those idea into MOO3, but it would be impossible to keep all of the ideas originally thought of, it would simply be to much, or to complicated, to...well, you get the idea, no matter how hard you try, not all concepts can work together, so some have to go.

Before people start bashing about feature cuts you heard about, i suggest looking at the game itself, and see how many innovative ideas are still in it.

Quote:

Real-time combat is overrated, and almost always much worse than turn-based combat (as it encourages click-festing).

In general, yes, but i don't think MOO3 is like this.
From the moo3 site.

Quote:

Consider: You've got a HUMONGOUS fleet. Bigger than anything you ever saw in MOO2. You've organized into... what? A dozen or so Task Forces. That dozen "pieces" is what you're commanding in real-time. And we're not talking "twitch" real-time, either. No, this is more like HARPOON, Death Star approaching Yavan "cinematic" real-time. Ample for you to think under the pressure and easy for you to issue commands on the Fleet and Task Force level.

For me it's actually a good sign that QS/IG delayed the release, after what happened with civ3/ptw.

Re: Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

Quote:

Originally posted by gregebowman:
Any idea when MOO3 will come out? Last time I looked in PC Gamer magazine, they said the game had already been released, yet I still don't see it in the stores.

Rumors are late january at its earliest, other say 28th february, i'm thinking it will be 28th february

Re: Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

"and MOO3 has the one feature that I hate most about SE4: SIMULTANEOUS MOVEMENT. I hate and despise it, it's like a compromise between turn based and RTS. If you want TBS, play TBS, if you want RTS, play RTS but SM is just stupid."

IMO simulatious is the BEST way to go about things. No excessive time pressure like in a RTS, and you avoid the "my men are sitting there doing nothing and dying" issue with turn-based.

Phoenix-D

Re: Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

ah, here is the cutlist:
http://moo3.quicksilver.com/official/cutlist.html

I actually agree with most of the reasons they give for cutting these features, wether it is the best solution or not, it isn't just random axing.

Re: Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

Quote:

Originally posted by Phoenix-D:
"and MOO3 has the one feature that I hate most about SE4: SIMULTANEOUS MOVEMENT. I hate and despise it, it's like a compromise between turn based and RTS. If you want TBS, play TBS, if you want RTS, play RTS but SM is just stupid."

IMO simulatious is the BEST way to go about things. No excessive time pressure like in a RTS, and you avoid the "my men are sitting there doing nothing and dying" issue with turn-based.

Phoenix-D

I'm with Phoenix-D on this, although the SE4 system could be improved with more orders (such as pursuit, join fleet, and engagement/retreat parameters).

PvK

Re: Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

"such as pursuit, join fleet, and engagement/retreat parameters"

The first can be done. Use the attack command. If they can't fight the target for whatever reason, they follow it. (works on allied ships- your ships park in their sector and follow them if they leave)

Phoenix-D

Re: Anyone think Masters of Orion 3 will be any good??

Quote:

Originally posted by Imperator Fyron:
I think that SE: System Wars has been put on hold.

I don't think so. I think they changed the name, thats all.

Quote:

Originally posted by Thei R'vek:
... and MOO3 has the one feature that I hate most about SE4: SIMULTANEOUS MOVEMENT. I hate and despise it, it's like a compromise between turn based and RTS. If you want TBS, play TBS, if you want RTS, play RTS but SM is just stupid.

I think it is a great way to get the best of both worlds.