Re: STACKERS, newbie game, (started)
 

(Been chatting with Blackguard over PMs, he suggested I drop this into the thread for a better view of my mentality on all this, so why not.)

Re: STACKERS, newbie game, (started)
 

I feel that the sabotage is very regrettable, but I have about the same level of sympathy for BG as he expressed when my turns staled.
For me personally, the game is now more interesting and balanced and I would prefer to play on, but can accept the rollback if that is the wish of the majority.
If Gandelf can insure that it doesn't happen again, why not? Depending on how you interpret the stats, Rlyeh is still the #1 or #2 nation out there.

Re: STACKERS, newbie game, (started)
 

Well allowing the AI of Rlyeh to go thru will insure that it doesnt happen to Rlyeh again.
Whether it can happen again depends on the passwords of the players.

But I can leave the watch routine running, and the fact that its now recording who uploads what files can be a deterrent to future efforts.

Re: STACKERS, newbie game, (started)
 

There are still a good few titanic clashes to go, yep.

Re: STACKERS, newbie game, (started)
 

Hmmm. Think of the bad turn as a handicap to the game leader?

I don't think just setting to AI is the answer since I will be able to take advantage of that.

How about this ... we all agree that nobody can enter the water (except maybe scouts for arms control verification). Turn the AI on for R'leyh and it would be a permanent hazard to nearby players.

Re: STACKERS, newbie game, (started)
 

Thinking on this over night and seeing responses such as this in the morning, i'm left feeling rather annoyed about how this has been handled.

Seeing as you are quick to point out facts (which are actually not facts but mere speculation), let me run through some other 'facts'...

1. The probability of Gandalf' server being hacked are minimal
2. The probability of someone guessing your PW are minimal

Seeing as you are a master of 'facts' here are some other possibilities.

a)You changed your turn and the actions of your units to enable you to come on the forum and cause a ruckass.

b)You have someone living at your house with whom you share your computer with and they logged on and mucked up your turn as a prank.

Frankly BG, you did point the finger and did name names - no matter how much you spin it. The unwashed crettin like manner in which you have conducted your self is appalling.

If you don't want to play on fine - but i dont vote for a roll back. The probabilities that the issue is on your end is far greater than someone in the game interfering with your turn.

Re: STACKERS, newbie game, (started)
 

Well, I certainly prefer it to setting it AI with you able to enter. ;)

An intriguing idea. I'm in favor of the agreement.

Re: STACKERS, newbie game, (started)
 

It would be better if R'leyh could be removed from the game, but I don't know if that is possible. Just so everyone knows I have about 4 of R'leyh's water provinces right now. Two of which are just raids and soon to be lost.

Re: STACKERS, newbie game, (started)
 

Before all this hullabaloo happened, I'd been talking with blackguard about the game a bit, and we had a discussion or two about his strategy. Having had those conversations, I think there is about a 0% chance that he sabotaged his own turn. While it makes for amusing speculation, it makes no sense and certainly does not fit with my knowledge of his intentions for the game. And probability 2 is pretty minimal, you'd have to actually know how to play the game to sabotage the turn in the way it was done, and know the password he was using.

Anyway, accusing each other isn't getting this game anywhere, so you guys may as well just stop. Seriously there is no point to arguing about this, whatever bad blood there is between you. It looks like either:

1) You guys roll back the turn, gandalf hosts the game with everyone's old turn and hopefully blackguard still has his old one and can submit that to gandalf, OR everyone redoes the turn. From now on gandalf puts all his cheat protections into place for this game, and you guys accept that there may be some bugginess that could kill the game later.

or 2) Blackguard goes AI, you guys decide whether going underwater is kosher or not, and gandalf still should probably place all cheat protections in place for this game since there's an extremely high probability one of the players is a cheater.

Alternatively, end the game right now, knowing that one sad, sorry excuse for a gamer just ruined the game for everyone, because if blackguard goes AI there's a very high probability the course of the game will be forever changed. Not to say he'd win, but he was strong enough that win or lose, he was going to really hurt anyone he warred with, making them much easier for neighbors to kill if nothing else.

Re: STACKERS, newbie game, (started)
 

I would say end the game. I'm not a part of it, so I have no say, but I have been following it here and on IRC. The best choice is to end the game now. There has been obvious cheating, and that is not a part of the Dom3 community.