Re: OT: Season 3 BSG
 

http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/laugh.gif http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/image...es/biggrin.gif

Re: OT: Season 3 BSG
 

Lorien would certainly add a touch of class to BSG...

Re: OT: Season 3 BSG
 

Actually, There is no proof of Tigh's involvement in the first war. See, we only know of his involvement from his own account, computer records, and billy's comment that he was once a published military historian after the war.

Adama, however, met him 20 years prior to the miniseries. The war was 40 years prior. So could his history have been forged? yes.

Tyrol being a cylon would also resolve why Tyrol's time of Pegasus didn't pop up when Cain went to execute him - not that it would've mattered.


On a side note, RDM has repeated comments like this many times: "I'm making this up as I go, there is no master plan."

Re: OT: Season 3 BSG
 

And that line right there is the sign that a series should just end.

Re: OT: Season 3 BSG
 

Dont care if I'm in the minority on this, I thought the season was a good one, with 2 or 3 standout shows, and 5 or six WOW moments that made me glad that BSG was re-made.
Even when I didn't like something, I was still interested. I hope it goes on for 2 more years.

Of course, 'Heroes' is even better with almost triple the Wow moments.

Still, BSG will have a nice chunk of the little TV I still watch.

P.S. some of my best roleplaying Gamemastering moments were "off the Cuff - and on the Fly' (of course a few tanked as well, hehehe)

Re: OT: Season 3 BSG
 

Unfortunately it just makes for bad TV. The best TV shows have all been ones that have had forethought and planning put into them. Every time a show starts caving to the demands of ratings rather than the demands of the fans it's just a downward spiral.

Re: OT: Season 3 BSG
 

All for All, no one can really complain about this new BSG when compared to the 70's version. And it has had a longer run thanks to it not being a continuation in any shape or form.

But it's failure lies in it moving away from the points made in the first season and miniseries.

I remember the trailer tagline for the tv series before it started. "Other stories start at the beginning, this one starts at the end." and then a shot of a big mushroom cloud.

In the first season and first half of season 2, BSG was very much a show of survival. BSG needs to get back to that.

Re: OT: Season 3 BSG
 

I could have sworn that one of the Cylon models was referred to as #2.

I think that isn't really fair to the 70's version. In a sense, the original BSG was more "A New Hope" while the new BSG is more "Revenge of the Sith".
The production value of the new is clearly better, and the plot is less basic... but there is a trend to equate confused with complex in modern drama, and as such I don't think the depth people attribute to the new series is entirely warranted.

Re: OT: Season 3 BSG
 

The whole inital reason I was turned off from new BSG was that from it's onset it only had a limited shelf life and the whole concept of maintaining a small population under heavy stress while pursued by a superior enemy limited how long it could last and what they could do with it. It appears I was wrong, but only by them taking the show in a whole other direction.

Re: OT: Season 3 BSG
 

Yeah. I'm not normally snarky on here for some reason, but occasional comments like that are not out of character.