Re: Some thoughts on improvements to the game
 

Come to think of it this might all boil down to the age-old preferences for forums. Thats a conversation Ive had often with many forum owners. There are many sliding scales with forums and one is how much preference the owner has for a quieter newbies ask and elites answer Q&A forum vs the more active higher noise ratio of community conversation newbies talk to newbies. How much are OT posts slapped, how much editing of threads, etc.

Re: Some thoughts on improvements to the game
 

"When all is said and done, there's much more said than done".

Sorta cuz its easier to talk than do = ).

Re: Some thoughts on improvements to the game
 

That isn't the issue. We aren't talking about non idea noise. The fact is there are more people coming up with ideas (regardless of quality) than there are people willing to implement the ideas of others. As evidenced by the many, many threads like this and the near total lack of results from them.

Re: Some thoughts on improvements to the game
 

Im sorry.
But I feel thats just an impression. I think that many of the conversations like this did end up creating something which everyone went on to enjoy. I would not give it a 90%-or-greater failure rate at all.

Im also quite aware that if I did give it a percentage it would just be my own impression and probably be just as incorrect on the other side of the real setting. But there are only a few major threads that stick in my mind as completely failed conversations while many come to mind as producing worthwhile results. Much fewer results would have come about if the person didnt bring it up as an idea first but simply pursued it on their own.

Re: Some thoughts on improvements to the game
 

I agree with you gandalf. I have seen many ideas implemented here, as the result of discussion.

Re: Some thoughts on improvements to the game
 

"Much fewer results would have come about if the person didnt bring it up as an idea first but simply pursued it on their own."

That's patently untrue. There would be far more out there in terms of mods, utilities and games if people actually did something about their ideas rather than posting them up for someone else to do (which almost never happens).

chrisp - discussion of the game is a very different beast from idea threads like this.

Re: Some thoughts on improvements to the game
 

It may not have Dom3 results, but it's given me some ideas for my GURPS project. The comment on infinitely long battlefields, for instance[1].

-Max

[1] The insight here being that you can be infinite in only one dimension without hurting the tactical complexity much if at all, while possibly making the UI and gameplay more fun.

Re: Some thoughts on improvements to the game
 

For some people the glass is half full.
For some people the glass is half empty.
For some people the glass is made of glass and it could break and cut you.

My friends always tell me I'm #3.

Re: Some thoughts on improvements to the game
 

Ahhhh I see. We are not talking about the same thing. Not quite anyway.

What you say is true. IF every idea was tackled by the initial person and completed then there would be more. But that isnt very likely.

On the other hand, some of our best stuff would not have happened without someone bringing up the idea and someone else finishing it.

It wouldnt take many suggested-that-someone-else-finished to outnumber the number that were finished by a DIY response. My impression is that most of those simply died on the vine, or were sloppily done then taken up by someone else anyway.

Not to mention that some of the most interesting discussions on here would not have happened. :)

Re: Some thoughts on improvements to the game
 

I don't think it ever hurts to put ideas up, whether or not they are implemented. First rule of brainstorming is not to stifle any ideas, no matter how impractical they seem. If 100 ideas are put forward and out of them 1 great one is picked up and implemented by someone, then they are all worthwhile.

Besides, who knows which great idea will spark renewed interest in Dom3 by the devs?