Re: Best item
 

I'm moderately sure that the damage is a constant value that does not depend
on the commander's strength. For some reason, Firebrand seems way more effective
against troops with neither resistance, which makes me believe that the fire damage
is armour piercing while the cold is not.

Re: Best item
 

My general impression has been that the AoE effect off of those weapons does somewhere in the range of 6-7 damage. Enough to kill a normal human solider, and therefore clear an a single square with three of them in it, with two attacks from the AoE weapon.

Jazzepi

Re: Best item
 

From the db:

Small Area Fire is a 14 point AP attack. Small Area Cold is a 12 point AP attack.

Interestingly, Ember's Small Area Frost and Fire is a 15 point AP attack with no cold tag, followed by Small Area Fire.
Is this a db error or a bug?

Re: Best item
 

14 ap fire and 12 ap cold respectively. So fire brand is clearly superior of the two. AP+AP damage, with the second AP being higher than the frost equivalent and less units that are immune to it.

Re: Best item
 

DB error, it should have the cold tag. Thanks for catching that.

Re: Best item
 

My pleasure :-)

I agree on the superiority of the brands
 

just recall that there are several small area fires - and without investigating them carefully (for other weapons or effects) it may not be the ap14 version.

Re: I agree on the superiority of the brands
 

The db disagrees with you there - there may be different weapons with the effect, but they appear to use the same effect each time.

Re: I agree on the superiority of the brands
 

They all use the same SAF effect, since there is just one of those. Don't believe me, you're free to mod units to have different weapons starting from 1 and going up to 500+ so you can see for yourself, chris.

Re: Best item
 

Armor of virtue you can put it on a mage have him cloud trapeze and cast wrathful skies. You can do it every turn and kill army after army. In fact I would like to know a counter to it.