Which nations represent order and good?
 

Edit: for clarification, the first question applies to EA, the second to MA, and the last to LA. I got a bit tired and copy-pasted one too many fields.

Same as before, looking for Good vs Evil, Order vs Chaos themes. Nations with grudges against each other, eg Pythium and Ermor, or Lanka and Kailasa are also helpful. Note, there are some nations like Marignon who might represent order, but are problematic because of the techniques they use (inquisitors!). This also makes things more complicated.

Re: Which nations represent order and good?
 

Please define good. By the way, I like Dominions because it's mostly free of such cliche concepts.

Re: Which nations represent order and good?
 

I interpreted most neutral but certainly not evil nations as falling in this category though

Re: Which nations represent order and good?
 

Okay, check out the post on evil nations for contrast..

http://www.shrapnelcommunity.com/thr...&type=post

Actually one of the tricky things about Dominions is that sometimes I think all the nations are evil in the sense that they are probably mostly fairly authoritarian and brutish societies and they all want to win at the expense of all the other nations (at least if their pretender god has his or her way).

But if we step back a bit, well there are a lot of neutral nations, a few that fit fairly closely to Judeo-Christian standards of "goodness" or "godliness". Caelum comes to mind - they're a bunch of winged angels after all. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif Let's just say for now the good or neutral nations are the ones who do not rely heavily on death or blood magic, do not enslave minds and generally treat their people better than the evil nations. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif

Re: Which nations represent order and good?
 

None of the nations are good as such. PRactically all of them would have cultural practices that would range from suspect to outright horrifying from a humanist perspective. From the same premises, it is however easy to define several nations as evil.

Re: Which nations represent order and good?
 

Yeah, I think you are right. The question of what is good is interesting though. Technically if you were one of the citizens of those nations, being good would mean doing what your pretender god wants you to do, even if it meant dealing out some of Old Testament style havoc upon the unbelievers. Of course today, from a humanist standpoint we would consider such acts atrocities or war crimes.

Dominions has some interesting religious implications when you sit down and think about it. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif

This kind of changes the concept of the game I wanted to put together though. Instead of Good vs Evil, it has become Not As Bad vs Evil. This is the problem I used the idea "Good or Order", which I'm afraid only complicates things

Re: Which nations represent order and good?
 

I'm not sure how to vote; so many of them benefit from order scales, and I haven't played all of them yet.

I am reasonably sure that LA C'tis and Agartha aren't evil, or are at least ethical for necromancer-based nations.

Re: Which nations represent order and good?
 

Any nation that stops my plan of world domination is evil.

Re: Which nations represent order and good?
 

Who voted for Yomi in EA? I'd love to hear why.

Re: Which nations represent order and good?
 

Im honestly Bogarus got any votes. While they may have an amount of intellectual "Freedom" Im not sure the religion could be considered friendly, even to their own people.