![]() |
US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Aaron Russo, hollywood producer, made this very interesting documentary about TAX and how it is a fraud against America and is completely unconstitutional. In fact Income Tax is illegal by our own laws. It is very interesting video. Enjoy.
America Freedom To Fascism |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Man the more I watch this documentary the more I really begin to get scared. The people interviewed in this film are not crack pots from far flung websites, many of them are credible accomplished professionals. This is so much more than tax. The film deals with the entire spectrum of how we are moving away from being a true free society to enslaved one. This is a MUST watch video. You really need to watch this. It will scare the hell out of you. However, like with all films in this genera, you have to consider that it is a manipulation peace. That elements of it more than likely have been taken out of context. However it still is one of those kinds of films that make 1984 seem like commercial for Freedom.
About 1 hour 22 minutes or so into the film they begin to talk about why your personal information is so important to them. It is a dramatization but it is a very effective one. A guy calls Pizza Palace to order dinner. You won't believe what they can do with your personal information from the books you read to your last doctor office visit. Watch the movie. It is extremely thought provoking. From the 2008 National ID to tagging every American with ID radio chips. PDL's and such will become a reality as sure as the sun sets. They do take some things out of context, like the Tazering of a women in New York, but for the most part it does a very effective job at scaring the hell out of one. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
There are legtimate problems with the US today. Income tax isn't one of them.
Something like, oh, this: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/6512945.stm is. Holding someone for 5 years before trial, a trial that results in a 9 month sentence and an arguable coerced plea bargin. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
go start your own thread phoenix.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
People have been trying the "income tax is unconstitutional" argument ever since it was enacted. Hasn't ever held up in court.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
it has held up in court when the judges allow the defense motions. however, most judges don't allow these motions because they know that to do so would be opening the flood gates. also all because people loose doesn't make what they are doing wrong, it proves that the system is rigged to keep the lie alive and people in line. watch the film and make your own opinion. don't just blow it off as bs.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
The people who make these anti-tax documentaries are the same people that support government policies that piss away money. They need to shut their pie hole and pay taxes and maybe vote in favor of small government instead of checking yes on every politician that says he'll bring more money slush funds to his state.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_protester_arguments |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Warning: Wondering Rant To Follow.
The guy who made this anti-tax video didn't make an anti-tax film. He is also not Micheal Moore. Sure this movie is filled with the usual manipulation of facts, but if you sift through the facts, you will find that there is some truth to what is being said. No where in the film does the film maker say "don't pay your taxes" on the contrary, they tell you to pay them. A little back ground on the topic, paraphrased for ease of reading. The major bankers of the time, back in 1913, wanted to establish a system that would generate considerable wealth for which they themselves would have sole control of. They named this system the Federal Reserve. The Federal Reserve is where the US Government gets its money. However this isn't free money. The Federal Reserve simply makes the money, figuratively speaking as the US Mint actually makes the money, that the US Government then borrows. Now this money didn't exist before the Federal Reserve made it. It was simply none existent. However now that they have made it and loaned it to the US Government, the Government must pay it back and pay interest on it. That interest is what our national deficit is. To pay down this deficit an income tax was introduced and the IRS was formed to collect it. So in the simplest terms, the bankers of the Federal Reserve make money out of thin air, loan it to the US Government who then taxes you and I to pay it back with interest. The bankers of the Federal Reserve get top value for their money, while you and I get the least value for it. This is how they generate wealth and why the rich get richer and the poorer get poorer. Simply put, if you don't earn interest, you pay interest. All of this is just a system of greed established under false pretenses to enslave a nation of people by tricking them into accepting a system of debt paid for by an income tax. We have been duped into giving our hard earned money away under illegal conditions to a system that was created by the elite wealthy and enforced by our own Government. This by its very nature is one of many known definition of slavery. [Rant] My whole point is this, when there is no law compelling you to pay your income tax, only the might and force of the IRS making you, then there is something wrong. We are a nation of laws, a Republic, not a totalitarianism. When force is used to make you do something that there is no law telling you that you must do, than that is contrary to the beliefs and practices of our very way of life. It makes us slaves to the system. Congress simply needs to reform the entire income tax system. Abolish the power that the few power broking big banks have at the Federal Reserve, re-organize the IRS and pass a real income tax law. They need to be accountable for the money we pay in. Right now most of the income tax we pay goes to pay the interest on the money that the US Government borrows from the Federal Reserve. The Federal Reserve is no more a part of the government than Federal Express is. The Federal Reserve is in fact a cartel of large banks, most of whom no one, including the President, don't even know all the names of. I ask you, since the US Dollar is no longer tied to our nations precious metal reserves, what backs it? Economics of paper money, especially money that is quite literally just printed without any measure to its backing, is a recipe for disaster. The Federal Reserve, the central bank, is also a key stone of communisms. Our nation worked fine from 1776 to 1913 without the Federal Reserve and income tax. The whole system is flawed and really needs to be overhauled. Right now as it is, the system only creates wealth for the rich. The middle class is evaporating, and no one is investing in education because the powers behind the system want our children, and by extension the American population, to be stupid. Think about it, knowledge is power and if you have a well educated populous, then the chances are people are going to figure out how the game is being played and manipulated and then they will affect change. If you keep your population dumbed down, in debt, brain washed by cooperate owned entertainment and news organizations, and tied to working three jobs just to survive, they will never question the system and those running it. The American dream, yes that is an accurate statement because you have to be asleep to believe it. No one wants to affect change because they are complacent with what they have. That nice car, that nice home, the food on the dinner table, and that 36" flat screen TV hanging on the wall keep us all in line. Mean while we shelling out those income tax and interest payments. We have been, all of us, enslaved to a system for which we know not, but love so. In 2008 the National ID card system will begin. While this sounds like a good idea on paper, in all honesty it will remove much of your amenity and allows any one who so choses to track you. While I doubt I will ever be asked to show my papers in my life time, I do believe that it is entirely possible that the children of today will at some point in their lives, be required to show theirs just to travel from state to state. While this all seems like some conspiracy theory on caffeine, keep in mind that virtually every one now has a debt card, a credit card, and is in debt up to their eyes. How many of you still carry cash? Why would congress pass a law reforming the bankruptcy protection laws in order to favor the credit card industry who now charge an average of 26% interest on money you borrow from them? No protection was added for you, in fact it was stripped away in favor of protecting the credit card companies. The very agency, the Controller of the Currency, that is tasked with regulating the credit card industry is funded by the credit card industry. That is a kin to the Mob being protected by the police. The same thing can be said about the IRS. They are the mob, and if you don't pay they will show up and break your legs or worse. And the two political parties, the Democrats and the Republicans, well they are like the Gambino's and the Soprano's. Sure once in a while one of them might shoot the other, but when you start messing with their game, they pull together and put a stop to it real quick. And all of this ties back to the Federal Reserve and income tax. There is no law of record that compels any American citizen to pay income tax. The only reason we do pay it is because if we don't, the IRS will destroy us. The system is designed and protected by fear. You fight it, and you will loose because no one within the system wants to fight the system out of fear that they will be next. Judges included. Even though The Supreme Court has ruled against the IRS and income tax, 99% of the dependents in tax cases are prohibited by the judges in those cases from pointing out the Supreme Court ruling to their juries. Why? Because if people were educated to the fact that there is no law compelling them to pay their income taxes, then they wouldn't and the system would begin to break down. And most fear that chaos would then ensue without considering that whole system is less than a hundred years old and that for over a hundred years our nation ran fine without it. If they want us to pay income tax then they need to reform the tax code and establish an amendment that actually says we must pay income tax. Currently, according to the Supreme Court, the 16th Amendment does not give the government the right to levy new taxation against the American people. In other words it didn't give our government the right to establish an income tax. I believe that we all have a responsibility to each other to keep out nation strong. I believe that taxes are a necessary evil even if our founding forefathers felt otherwise. While I don't agree with the current income tax system, a system ripe with corruption, unfairness, greed, and abuse, I know that it is all we have. I also know that any one who has ever tried to bring about reform of this system has paid for it dearly. You might want to know that the Tax code is not a law, that Government does not have the right to seize your personal belongings in order to collect for an illegal tax. Right now as it is, there is no law stating that you are required to pay income tax. The fact that we do pay it, and that we allow the IRS to seize the property of those who don't pay and to throw them into jail is purely out of fear that we will be next. Now I ask you, does that sound like we live in a free society? And I ask you, if you believe that the people you elect to office are really looking out for your best interests when they themselves were elected through the efforts of a very expensive campaign, who do you believe they owe? The people who elected them, or the people who funded their election? Given your wishes over their money you will loose out each and every damn time. Just look at the bankruptcy reform act for evidence of that. And the beautiful part of it is, people actually believe that the reform was needed. The wonders of believing what they want you to believe never fails to effect change. When they own the information, they can bend it any way they want. I guess the question is can we change the system. The answer is no. Baring a nuclear disaster of epic proportions, the system will continue and we will follow where it leads. Like Democracy, we are the lone sheep standing beside the two wolves as they discuss whats for dinner. And the epically sad truth is, we haven't a clue that we are about to be devoured. [/Rant] |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Quote:
Unlike you, Atrocities, I do not surf the Web actively searching out stuff that will just depress me. I do not need to watch the film to form an opinion, because there isn't a word of it that I haven't heard before. Nothing yet mentioned in this thread is news to me. I'm not blowing it off because it's BS, I'm blowing it off because it's just more of the same. Anyone who's worried about the national ID doesn't realize how much data is already out there. We are the most documented and dossiered culture in world history; one more number in the databases isn't going to change anything at this point. Since I've already cut half of what I've typed, I'm going to quit now before I really cut loose and get in trouble with the moderators. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
I am very happy for you in that you are happily putting that psychology degree to good work by psychoanalyzing me and asserting your opinion about my web surfing habits. Your check is in the mail.
I get that you don't care about the topic because you have heard it all before but please don't attack me because I posted the information. You never know, perhaps someone might come along who hasn't read this before and might find it an interesting topic. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Everything has its pros and cons. Absolutes are the territory of fanatics so they are easily ignored.
I do not believe that taxes are wrong. Neither do I think that all of the present taxes have been done correctly. This is a subject that can stand scrutiny. And I find it interesting, and worth watching, the views about the legality of what has happened. Gandalf Parker |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Government: The process of taking something simple and complicating it.
That's what happened to our tax system. Income tax is a good thing and it is legal - despite what evil boogie man conspiracies theories and tax protesters claim. So we need to vote for smaller government -- and vote for candidates we can trust to do exactly that, if we can't find one we'll need to become one ourselves. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
My biggest complaint about our tax system is that double taxation is supposed to be illegal. But yet Richard and I have to pay tax to two cities because he works in one city and we live in another. Combined that with the fact that our city doesn't allow any exemptions and we pay more in local taxes than we do in state taxes. Gosh I can't wait until we're in a position to move.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Quote:
All I am saying is this. Make it legal. If the government wants an income tax than fine, make it a law to shut up all the nae sayers. Then reform the IRS and the Tax Code. There is no excuse for someone making 60 million a year to pay less in taxes than someone making 25k working two jobs. Mindi your situation must be extremely frustrating. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/frown.gif Have people tried to change the law to help improve or at least reduce the double taxation? |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Nope, because the cities don't want to lose the tax, so they won't even work together to fix it. So we get taxed 2% for where Richard's full time job is (which is an hour commute each way btw) and 1.75% for where we live. Lancaster (where we live) does give you a credit for tax paid to other cities (even though they don't ever see that money as there is no cooperative agreement) but they only allow you to have a credit for a maximum of 1%. So we pay a total of 2.75% in local city taxes.
On top of which we now pay starting this year 1.5% school tax as the school system cooerced a tax that BARELY passed (and there is speculation about whether or not it really did pass, but I digress) by cutting off bussing to high schoolers and making the tax only on earned income, so anyone living on a pension, fixed income, investors, etc doesn't have to pay it. However that leaves those like Richard and I (no children, working hard and having to work outside of Lancaster as there are no IT jobs in little Lancaster, Ohio) paying the equivalent of 4.25% in LOCAL taxes and getting very little benefit as even if we had kids, I wouldn't send them to school here and the roads are always in need of repair. RIDICULOUS! Okay that's my rant for the day, I just got done doing our taxes last week, so the wound is fresh! lol Frankly, I am a big lover of a flat tax. It would get all that hidden under the table income and you can control how much you are paying in taxes. The more you spend the more you pay, it's that simple. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
The constitution has a section in it that discusses taxes and that they have to equal and not punitive. I forget what it was called, but it meant that everyone pays the same. A flat tax.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
"The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States;"
All that says is the tax law can't vary from state to state. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Thank you. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif It has been some time since I read it, as I mentioned. Uniform is an interesting word though.
Quote:
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Just google it- there's a lot of sites that provide the text. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif
What cheeses me off is some of them are trying to SELL it, and right now one of those is #1 in Google ranking. WTF people? Its a legal document, not your own book! |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Quote:
Even if it did, you think they were saying that federal tax cant vary from state to state but state tax can? You really think thats why they put that line in? |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Atrocities, you forget the states and local governments can do pretty much whatever they want if the federal government hasn't claimed it.
The way it is phrased, the 16th amendment, when used under Article One of the United States Constitution at section eight or better known as the "Necessary-and-proper clause", clause 18 gives the government the power to tax any income as it would be an "Income Tax". Now the states and local government under the 10th amendment pretty much have the right to abuse the people and tax them all they want -- which they routinely do. Down here in Orlando, we have several highways going in and out of town, but only one is toll free. That's the county nickel and dime'ing the locals. The city of orlando is constantly "tweaking" property appraisals which increase the taxation of property without a tax hike (ie, higher property values mean higher taxes). And the state of florida seems to be on the verge of dropping the low sales tax in favor of a steep services tax on small businesses and out of state distributors. So really, is it the Income Tax being a burden or the States abusing their powers... again! Mindi, your situation is insanity, hopefully you and richard both can get out of it or the situation changes soon. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Thanks Azselendor, unfortunately I don't expect things to change around here anytime soon. We're just going to get to the point where we can move and try to move out into the country outside of city jurisdiction so we won't have to worry about being taxed twice..also much closer to Richard's full time job as commuting as much as he does is a royal pain in the you know where, lol.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Quote:
I am too stressed out right now to pay any further attention to this thread. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
I wish you well Capnq. Stress can be a killer.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Quote:
Section 9, Article 4. No capitation, or other direct tax shall be laid unless in proportion to the census or enumeration herein before directed to be taken. <<"Capitation" means 'head tax' or tax on individuals. Supposedly this was altered by 16th Amendment, but a Supreme Court decision claims otherwise.>> 16th Amendment Passed by Congress July 2, 1909. Ratified February 3, 1913. The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever sources derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration. Notice that the 16th Amendment does not mention "capitation" -- that is, direct taxes on individuals. So, maybe the Supreme Court was right? |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Thank you Baron. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif I was looking for a way to explain the complexities of this issue and you cut right through and nailed the crux of it. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Baron: first, that was for another part of the argument, not the original post. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif See AT's post right above that one.
Second, read Amendment 16 again. "The congress shall have the power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever sources derived. That overrides Section 9 article 4 prett clearly, and I'd be curious to see the Court case that says otherwise. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
The thing is, does this Amendment mean "lay and collect taxes on incomes whatever sources derived" for individuals for for cooperations? I don't believe the Amendment was clear in that regard and that is one of the reasons why the Supreme Court ruled that the Amendment did not give the Government the right to levy new taxes against individuals because up to that point only cooperations were being charged an income tax.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
From whatever sources derived is pretty clear AT, and I have yet to see a Court decision that says otherwise.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Yeah, after posting I considered the problem of context. Even the original clause doesn't prohibit the 'capitation' taxes, it just says they have to be proportioned according to the census. Implicitly, then, they are already allowed under that condition. So you can see how the SC would say 'the 16th Amendment didn't grant any new powers of taxation' (it just removed a restriction on how they are applied) and the angry people who thought it did wouldn't understand that it meant 'you don't have a case' rather than 'we agree with you'.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Here's an excellent interview of Aaron Russo where at the 53 minute point he explains why 9/11 needed to be orchestrated in order to facilitate the enslavement of the American people.
http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...0918&hl=en An excellent documentary on how 9/11 was used to try to take away the rights of Americans can be seen here: http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...26890127819985 |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
I like Russo, he cracks me up and to some small degree has made some very good points about things that make you go "hummm."
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Slaughtermeyer, why is this latest conspiracy post of yours in a thread about income tax? Off-topic spamming of other threads doesn't help your case.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Aaron Russo made a movie that deals with both topics. So he is actually on topic to some degree.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Oh, my apologies, then. There wasn't anything in his post to indicate that.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Why are you complaining? Your taxes are practically nonexistant http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif A couple of pizzas a month.
If Illwinter wants to pay its emplyed workers (me and JK) the company will have to pay approximately 50% taxes on wages (social tariffs or something). When I get paid I have to pay taxes on my income. Income tax is approximately 30%, depending on where you live. So when Illwinter recieves 1000 bucks from Shrapnel, I pay almost 66% of it in taxes. Then we have 25% VAT on all purchases. So consider yourselves lucky if you don't like taxes. I like taxes. When I bang my head into a wall for loosing money I can go to a doctor and pay approximately nothing to get my head fixed. When I afterwards get a remiss to psyciatric clinic it is equally free of costs. Then I get old and get paid for being old. I like taxes. Perhaps not when I pay them, but I'm quite confident there is not much that would suddenly destroy my life and leave me without support. I can pretty much afford a comfortable life (not from illwinter, but from my work as a teacher). Quote:
Since the banks have made the money it is reasonable to expect them to want to earn some money from their service. If I collected sea shells for the village to use as money I would like to gat paid. It would be a greedy scheme by me, but it would enable the villagers to trade without having to barter and they would probably like my sea shells. Some more than others. Quote:
Quote:
Sweden has been socialistic for about one hundred years, but the swedish society is more and more letting go of socialistic traits, and the current government is a right-wing alliance (though probably leftist by american standards http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif ). Communism evolved from socialism and share several ideological traits. As a good swede I like many of the socialistic traits of our society. I don't feel particulary enslaved, even though I live in a country that probably qualifies as built on communist key stones. The swedish central bank has sucessfully kept the inflation at 2% since the reform of 1994. It is no longer under the direct control of the government and is working surprisingly well. Quote:
But you are right. It is better to know what you do and what you get. THat is why it is important to educate yourself, and that is why I find my job important (teacher in social sciences). Quote:
Of course you will not! The system will continue and you will change it. It will evolve and others will make money out of it for a while, then it will change again, and the earlier powers will loose power. Some will at times feel as sheep, but the less of you that get an education the less of you will be sheepish http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif Just get rid of all that home-schooling and your country will prosper http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/happy.gif |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Everything changes sooner or later. I wonder if what replaces it will be better or worse?
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Eventually we will become the future as seen in the Star Trek series. We will either be the Federation (ultimate democrats) or the Ferrengi (ultimate republicans). Altho lately under Bush its been feeling more and more Romulan.
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
The sad thing is, I wouldn't want to live under the Federation as they ten to dictate how people should behave and they enforce their will upon others. If you want to live in our society, you have to follow our rules... and those keep changing depending upon our mood.
I don't think Bush is a Romulan, a Ferengi yes, a Romulan no. If you think Bush abused his power, wait until the next bastard, or women, gets into office. Then you are going to see some real right stomping, goose stepping, totalitarianism. I at least somewhat trust Bush, I do not however trust Clinton. Ever wonder what could happen if the wrong person now gets into office? We all know that Clinton fired all of the US Attorney's when he was elected and nothing was said, but Bush fires 10 and all hell breaks loose. Wait until Clinton is elected into office and see what the lady does. She will make bush and her husband look like lovable panda bears by comparison. I trust her to kick the crap out of any nation that attacks us, but there is a caveat. Like her husband, she too has a sweet spot for the old Chinese money, anti-freedom beliefs, and a strong tendency toward socialism, ala Stalin style, that frankly scares the hell out of me. (In other words, people are going to start disappearing once that *itch gets into office.) I am of the firm belief that someone like her, a power mad evil women of epic conniving proportions who is a master manipulating back stabbing professional liar should NEVER given the power or office of the Presidency. To do so would be to empower a monster that would make Stalin look like a weak sister. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Lol
|
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Quote:
**Which is rather ridiculous frankly, because during the Bush presidency the offices of the U.S. Attorneys across the nation investigated seven times as many Democratic officials as they investigated Republican officials, a number that exceeds even the racial profiling of African Americans in traffic stops. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
Yet we have lost both Dems and Reps to corruption over the last seven years. This just proves that even those whom we expect to be incorruptible can be corrupted. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/frown.gif
Think of the US economic system as a large credit card. The Federal Reserve is Citi-bank and they issued the US Government a credit card. Whenever the US government needs money they just go the US Mint access their Citi-bank visa and withdraw 10 billion. This money comes from no where, it is literally just printed up on credit. The US Government then taxes us to pay the interest that this illusionary borrowed money incurs. We all know how much trouble a person can get into with credit cards, now image that problem on the grand scale of our Government and won't take a crystal ball to see how this is going to end. |
Re: US Income Tax - Unconstitutional
"Daddy are we a democracy or a republic?"
"Neither son, we are a Capitalism." - Gandalf Parker |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:10 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©1999 - 2025, Shrapnel Games, Inc. - All Rights Reserved.