A great thousend people war, but why I lost?
 

http://www.erji.net/attachment/Mon_0612/12_211820.jpg

I think the battle has a limit about 50 round
after that, the attack side is forced retreat
however, the side break siege should retreat back to fort

sorry for may poor english

Re: A great thousend people war, but why I lost?
 

Hi pino !
I'm not sure what happened at your battle. But if one side choose to "break siege" this side is the attacking side. If unable to win, this side can *not* retreat back to the fortress. Make sure that a neighboring province is under your control before you try to "break siege".

Re: A great thousend people war, but why I lost?
 

The rule is that units can't retreat into a sieged fort, this prevents armies from other provinces getting inside the fort even though they couldn't break through the siegers. Since an army attacking from inside a fort can't be distinguished from one trying to break the siege from the outside (infact such armies combine if they attempt on the same turn) there is no easy way to make a special case where they can retreat back inside.

It doesn't completely make sense the way it is, but it's very unlikely to get changed.

Re: A great thousend people war, but why I lost?
 

I think that units should retreat to where come from...

anyway, if the retreated units get into a enemy country, should make a new battle, rather than all die

in my save game, I break siege in my last province...>_<

this rule make no sense..

Re: A great thousend people war, but why I lost?
 

Also, there is a 50 round limit on combats before everyone gets autorouted. IIRC there are another 50 round after that where everyone not routed gets auto-killed (in case there are any paralyzed folks stuck out there).

Though I thought the number of rounds was changed from dom2 to 3.

Re: A great thousend people war, but why I lost?
 

Pino,

I don't have an answer for you, but I am very curious what units you had that did such a great job of smashing the huge Ulmish army! Please tell!

Re: A great thousend people war, but why I lost?
 

Ten pimped up thugs/SCs?:) Thugs with good weapons and quickness from items don't need too much chaff to handless loads of infantry.

Still, the numbers are impressive.

Re: A great thousend people war, but why I lost?
 

Was this SP or MP? If SP, I'd like to know how the AI got 1800 guys in one province. http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/shock.gif

Re: A great thousend people war, but why I lost?
 

I've had AI dump over 1200 units on me quite early on a game:/

And I got beat so bad it pissed me off and I quit:)

Re: A great thousend people war, but why I lost?
 

Heh nice screenshot!
Quality > Quantity, eh? http://forum.shrapnelgames.com/images/smilies/laugh.gif