[Captain Kwok]

***This Post Contains Spoilers ***

Atrocities:

I disagree with the weak plot - that is not true - sure it had some nitpicks, but so does every movie including First Contact!

The complaint re: Shinzon's forces is a common one by a lot of Star Trek fans. If you listen to the dialogue carefully, you can see how it might have been accomplished:

Shinzon was mentioned as an important commander during the Dominion war and fought and won with the Reman forces during the worst conflicts of the war. So, he would be respected by the Remans for sure and valuable to the Romulans. The Schimitar, Shinzon's ship, didn't need to a secret project. I'm sure the Romulans are just as good as building starship prototypes like the Federation. It was probably given to him by the conspirators to command, as part of the plot against the Romulans. Since he had the support of most of the military including the Reman forces and the stated fact "governemnt changes" occur frequently on Romulus, it's not far fetched at all!

Wow. Not so far-fetched eh?

The B-4 acquisition is a little rushed - I suppose they could have found a better way of acquiring him - but it wasn't so bad as some people make it seem.