View Single Post
  #189  
Old March 8th, 2003, 11:28 PM
jimbob's Avatar

jimbob jimbob is offline
First Lieutenant
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Posts: 738
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
jimbob is on a distinguished road
Default Re: OT of OT: Rating Fyron -- no longer possible

Errr...

I know that everyone since about oh, I guess a few hundred years ago now, are of the opinion that Galileo = good scientist and the Church = bad anti-scientists. However, the Chruch WAS science at that time. Universities were not controlled by the church, Universities (and the studies that happened with in them) were the church. To view it otherwise is IMnotsoHO simply a post-modern recreation of the social reality of that time.

That said, the "church fathers" who condemned Galileo were not condeming without reason. Their challenge was that his data was simply not rigourous enough to overthrow the overwhelmingly accepted science of the era, which indicated that the earth was indeed the centre of the universe. If his data had only been massaged the right way, it might have even been convincing (however, this is not to say that the other scientists/church fathers would have accepted or denied the data - that would be so hypothetical that it would only amount to hopeful interpretation or even slander either way).

It did happen later, that someone (his name eludes me at the moment) did massage the data in an approriate way. By attaching said Galilean data to eliptical orbits rather than Galileo's circular orbits, did the concept of a helio-centric solar system finally make good scientific sense. Until that point, helio-certrism was accepted on the basis of a faith that the simpler (though unsubstantiated) system was more likely to be correct. Note: this is not an Occam's razor arguement, because Occam's says that "all things being equal, the simplest Version is likely the more accurate". In this case, the simplest Version was not equal, because the math was way to difficult preceding the elipse.

Of course, it's easier to just say that church = bad, Galileo = enlightened in those Jr/Sr Highschool text books
__________________
Jimbob

The best way to have a good idea is to have lots of ideas.
-Linus Pauling
Take away paradox from the thinker and you have a professor.
-Søren Kierkegaard
Reply With Quote