[Ran-Taro]

Originally posted by Loser:

quote:

---

Originally posted by Ran-Taro:
However, all things being equal, the simplest explanation is, logically, the most likley to be true.

I am not going to go into what constitutes 'evidence' or the appropriate use of 'probably'. But you are again misusing the word 'logic'. Logic is very strict, and the simplest explanation is, logically, only the simplest explanation, nothing more.

I recommend you use a different word for now. Later take a course in Philosophy or Debate or some such, if you wish to wield 'logic' to favor your opinions.

Again, I'm not saying you are wrong or even that I disagree with you. But logic means certain things, and I do not want to see it abused the way 'ironic' is these days.

[edit: 'Reasonably' fits pretty well.]

---

Actually, I am not misusing the word 'logic' at all. I understand perfectly the definition of the word, and the way in which I choose to use it here is correct to both its proper and common meanings.

I would recommend that you do not patronise others with misguided assumptions about their knowledge, or their educations. As an example, I have studied philosophy at a tertiary level and am quite well versed in the use of terms associated with the discipline.

I don't feel it was nessesary to play the word Nazi (since my meaning was easily fathomable, and it didn't add anything to the discussion to nitpick it)*. However, if you feel a compulsion to do so, perhaps it might be useful to provide an actual definition, rather than just your opinionated judgment on the matter.

Here is a definition (according to the Maquarie Dictionary)

Logic n 1. the science which investigates the principles governing correct or reliable inference 2. reasoning or argumentation, or any instance of it 3. the system or principles of reasoning applicable to any branch of knowledge or study 4. reasons or sound sense, as in utterances or actions 5. convincing force: the irresistable logic of facts

(there are two more definitions, but they refer to electronics)

I believe that you are refering to definition 1. above in your post, and therefore (mistakenly) making the assumption that this is the only correct usage of the word 'logic'.

Even if you were correct in this assumption, you would still be incorrect in making the further assumption that I have misused the word. In this I refer you to the principle of:

Occam's razor n the principle that entities must not be unnecesarily multiplied, which as the principle of economy of hypothesis, is applicable to scientific research [from William of OCCAM]

[again from the Macquarie Dictionary]

I do not mean to be harsh, or start a fight. I can understand your frustration at 'word abuse'. However I would ask that if you are going to direct this frustration at me, could you please be accurate and defined when you do so. I do not enjoy being made out to be ignorant when I have chosen to use my words quite specifically and accurately.

And now, on with the discussion...

*Please note that I use both the words 'Nazi' and 'Nitpick' in their colloquial, rather than proper, senses here.