[spoon]

Originally posted by Imperator Fyron:
Now test those torp ships against APBs. And do some MBs for good measure.

Ran some more tests, all on Optimal Firing Range (Nearest, Has Weaps, Most Damaged, Strongest):

Based on Tonnage alone (50 battleships)
APB beat MB beat PPB beat Torp beat Null Space. (That's right, MB beat PPB. Never would have guessed that... MB won 6 out of 10).

Based on 1,000,000 resources (inc organic and rads), I had the following ship totals:
Torp: 56
APB: 53
MB: 50
PPB: 44
NSP: 36

APB beat everything (again)
MB beat Torps and PPB and NSP
Torps beat PPB and NSP
PPB beat NSP
NSP didn't beat anything