[PvK]

I think Peter's well-written argument still holds true though. It's not a suggestion to "fix" Tien Chi, but to fix conscription. That is, it should be fairly minor but noticable and worth something, and make sense. Currently, a low chance over a long time of going from zero to 1-3 PD, up to an eventual max of about PD 6, is extremely weak, hard to even notice, and worth very little. If it built up at a noticible rate up to about 10, and then slowly eventually might get up to 15-20, I'd say that would be about right.

Balancing the various themes of Tien Chi is a different matter altogether.

PvK