[Norfleet]

Originally posted by Graeme Dice:
They are very similar in cost, when you consider the gold spent on upkeep and purchasing, and don't consider the astral pearls from clams as part of the cost. After all, they are entirely free after 20 turns. Those mages cost 4000 gold, and the troops alone had an upkeep of 150. The water gem cost was around 140. That kind of conventional army should be able to destroy any lone unit with only minimal losses, or there is a serious balance problem.

By that logic, the astral pearls on YOUR clams are also free, and obviously, you've chosen to utilize them this way instead. Don't tell me you don't have them, you're Atlantis, *THE* top clam hoarding nation.

Furthermore, your army was tailored for a very poor fit against your opposition: Water mages, who are nearly entirely reliant on cold attacks for their battlefield spells, are very useless against a cold-immune target with high protection. They may as well have been complete non-participants, as you effectively sent them to their deaths.

Sea trolls are rather poor combatants for their cost: Their protection is substandard, and they generally underperform compared to standard trolls. The Sea King itself is a pure water mage, and suffers from the above....not to mention the number of casualties you inflicted on yourself by not isolating these dangerous, prone to Breath of Wintering water mages. Their only strength lies in the ability to be summoned on land and then marched into the sea to invade sea provinces...an advantage you more or less throw away by using them to fight on land. I do not think my empowered prestige pretender would have been necessary to drive your forces back into the sea: The ordinary, default model I started with should have been adequate, given the absolutely lousy force composition you chose for the job.

Look on the bright side: At least your upkeep is lower now.

[ April 09, 2004, 08:55: Message edited by: Norfleet ]