[Nagot Gick Fel]

Boron said:
Does "undead or lifeless are not affected" in spelldescription mean that i can't spam raise skeletons and they get reanimated as manikins too ?

Correct.

If the manikins created through haunted forest effect survive the battle do you keep them then or do they dissolve after battle ?

The later.

Furthermore spelldescription states that it works only in own dominion .
So i wonder how useful this spell is all in all ?

Obviously it's best used when you're on the defensive.

Swarm costs 1 nature gem but is 100 fatigue so the spell scripting ai should use more then 1 nature gem / swarm .

Not a real concern with nature-1 mages.

So you have the effect only in own dominion + either invest a lot of nature gems for swarm or have something like militia getting killed that you benefit from the spell ?

Exactly. Haunted Forest is pretty nasty with vanilla Pangaea if you have max turmoil, a fairly high dominion and enough Panii to supply an endless stream of maenads.

Is this really worth it when you can with zero gemcosts either spam false horrors or skeleton hordes ?

I didn't know that Pangaea could spam False Horrors so easily.

Anyway you didn't pay much attention to what I wrote: read that again, funniest devastating combo - devastating it surely is, and I can't easily imagine anything more funny in Dominions than watching at the chain reactions Haunted Forest may trigger - an unit dies, a manikin rises and kills an enemy nearby, a new manikin rises and kills another enemy unit nearby, a new manikin rises, etc. - all that in the same round! Spamming False Horrors gets rapidly boring in comparison.

And there is always the dispel problem.

Fact is, in that game my Haunted Forest Lasted only 1 turn . But spending 60 gems on it, plus 27 more on Swarms, to destroy 400 enemy units that were worth much more was quite a bargain. And I had no real choice anyway: in that game the Pangaean player I subbed for decided to quit because he found himself in a desperate situation, with his god killed, 7 depleted provinces left, the troops I listed plus an Apostate, a High Priest and a few scouts - nothing more! - and that big Arco army marching towards the capital, and only 2 provinces away from it.

I don't know what you would have done without troops in that situation, but I noticed that the Apostate had the items he needed to cast Haunted Forest - so I decided to alchemize every gem I had to nature and ended with 87 - enough for an unbuffed Haunted Forest and 3 Swarms/Dryad. So the Apostate performed the ritual , while the LQ and Dryads marched againts the invaders. And you know what happened . It sure didn't make me win that war, but at least it delayed Pangaea's extinction by several years!