After Action Reports are AFAIK written by the people who participated in the action. I think his CO never met him, right? Or do I have that wrong? WE do it in the Navy and USMC all the time today.
In any case, I don't feel qualified to judge the extent of a man's injuries, nor how they choose to deal with them. Everyone is different, and I don;t think any wound that leaves shrapnel still in one's leg thirty years later could be characterized as "piddly ant" - I do know though that he volounteered for the war when he could have gotten a deferment easily, while Cheney got 5 deferments and Bush, well, we all know what Bush did.
In any case, I do think the Vietnam thing is sort of silly as an issue - I don't think he should have emphasized it as much as he did - it was over thirty years ago. But by the same token, in war I want someone who's actually seen combat to lead a nation.
As to his testimony about atrocities being committed in Vietnam, he was recounting what other vets had told him, and, in any case, atrocities *were* committed.
I think very highly of a man who is willing to stand up in the face of his superiors and his fellows for what is right. Vietnam was a very nasty little affair - and it was the *wrong* war. Atrocities have been committed in Iraq (Abu Ghraib and others that will eventually see the light of day) and for someone today to stand up and shout that "hey that ain't right!" would be a service to the country.
To not say someything in the face of evil is to take the easy way out. I respect Kerry greatly for having the courage to speak out about evils being done in the name of the US. There is not much braver than that.
But, in any case, it was thirty years ago...
Quote:
Starhawk said:
Well his own CO said he wrote his own after acion report which is not only against military regs it can be punished by legal action (aka quarts martial).
Also as I said he got piddly ant wounds 3 times in a four month period that obviously didn't hurt him much then he ran home and bad mouthed his fellow soldiers in Nam and I mean entire UNITS not just individuals.
My great uncle stayed for 2 tours after getting hit twice (each was enough to put him out for a while) and he died so 4 months and copping out to go home when your comrades have to stay is bull.
Sorry but that's my feelings on Kerry, I think he is a liar as are all politicians but what bugs me about him is his danged "I Wont 3 purple hearts" big deal so you got in the way 3 times and got a skinned knee (or it's wartime equivalent) tens of thousands of other US soldiers got the purple heart after they died (can't remember the spelling of the word so I won't even try right now) so he's nothing special and should stop rubbing those in our faces.
|