Heh I like Starbuck for her kickass nature, but I like Boomer for her niceness and her hottness, OH and her dark hair

#6 is better looking without the wig
As for Galactica's anti-capital ship capabilities it kind of sounds like the entire Colonial fleet was 120 battlestars, they make no mention of smaller warships or support craft. Maybe she's got heavier weapons that we havn't seen yet:
Though Officially she has soemthing like 410 Defense guns and 14 main flak cannons, it makes no mention of primary batteries or missiles though we do hear Colonel Tigh and Adama talking about "Missiles bombs and munitions" so maybe we get to see missiles and main cannons later?