Geoschmo: Yes, I am following the steps in the manual for TCP/IP hosting, and I am choosing TCP/IP Host under connection type. We spent a good three hours last night trying to get it to work.
Suicide Junkie: *HEADDESK* You are my hero. That solved the problem. Every time we were going to mechanics first, making sure those were set right, and then going to set the game master password. Oh man.. I feel kinda stupid now
Thank you everyone who replied for helping me solve this. Now to find another night for a good all night spring break game
