[Will]

I hate to bring this up, but it always comes up inevitably...

So, AT... You just LOVED Starship Troopers, right?

A book can be excellent, top notch, worth reading five times over, lets-nominate-the-author-for-the-Nobel-Prize good ...

... and the cinema adaptation can be bad. (To draw from DNA) And not just bad, but jaw-droppingly bad. Bad on a big scale. Bad on a small scale. Bad when served with a side of toast. And in general, just reek of elephant excrement.

Anyway, the two of them are only paid to review movies. There isn't a need for them to go into the origins of the story, etc., only how they percieve what they see on the screen. That's what people what movie reviewers to do, only to say whether it is worth seeing a particular movie, or not.

--edit: stupid UBB code...