[WBWilder]

Scenarios should be winnable. If they are not, the player should be advised of that fact in the text before he begins.

Let the scenario be historical, but at the same time it should be playable, challenging and WINNABLE.

The whole idea of an historical scenario is to face history and then have the opportunity to change it. If you can't make a scenario that way, you should leave it alone.

Now I have not played this one and probably won't. That's not fair. I'll look at it but if it is as Jim describes, I may just pass on it or fix it so it is winnable. Nice thing about the editor (G)!

Wild Bill