On balance I still like the show. It's much better then most other junk on TV. The current plot arc does seem a bit clunky, but they seem to be rushing through it awfully fast. Skipping big chunks of time, as was mentioned in other posts. I'd be suprised if we aren't all back on the ships and on the way back to earth after a couple more episodes.
My one big gripe from the premiere...
******SPOLIER ALERT*******
... is how they make it look at the end of the episode how Rosalin is killed in the masacre, but then moments later sci-fi channel shows previews for next week where Rosalin is talking and is decidedly not dead. Hello, does anyone in marketing actually watch the show?
I like the bit about Starbuck though. They are really screwing with her mind badly. It's going to be interesting to see the crap she goes though to get back to the Cylon-butt kicking warrior we know and love. Facinating character development.