If being honest about what you think is being negative, well then I guess I am negative.
I like the show, however I just don't like the sudden shift that the series took and the lack luster way in which they transitioned from the old story line to the new one. I felt that could have been done a hell of a lot better than the rushed haphazard way it was done.
Most of what I have read on other forums supports my POV. While people like the show, there is a strong sense of confusion about the direction the plot has taken. BSG is fundamentally about human survival in the face of horrifying odds. To that end they have an auidance that will watch. But BSG is more than survival, its about the hope of humanity and the exploration of survival. Remember life here began out there, and it was those words that defined the journey for which BSG embarked upon. I hope, I sincerely do, that the producers of BSG haven't forgotten that. They have 18 more episodes to take the show where its going. I, for good or bad, hope to be along for the ride. I am sorry if that is a negative view, but its an honest one.