[Azselendor]

I'm with Atrocities, I think the new Battlestars from RDM's series would have fared significantly better against star wars ISD's and Vipers would have been superior to the TIE's as well (TIE's have to move like airplanes in space, vipers move like they are in space while in space)

Original Series Battlestars, I think were depicted fairly accurate, I don't recall any of the original series battlestars being in direct ship-to-ship combat and faring well.