I find myself using quite a lot of the summons that are noted as bad here, in some situations. Depending on my main stream mages and gem income and what kind of national troops I have. What summons are regarded the best, are usually those who fit in the best for some common cookie-cutter strategies. Agreed, some of them are a better option in almost any scenario.
Cave drakes and Scorpion beasts I tend to use to strenghten a line of "slightly" inferior infantry, so my mages and artillery gets enough rounds to kill the enemy.
All in all, I rate banes, naiad warriors and Sea kings court among the best. Mainly since I almost always use them if I have them available.
The eater of the dead though, is for SP only. And then only for the kicks of summoning something odd.
