This sucks. I must have really messed up when creating this game again. We did reset once, right? I remember that I set the VP requirement to win to 50 VPs when I created the (first) game. Because without a VP win condition, you can't have capital VPs. But it seems I forgot to change the slider the second time, because the VP win condition was only 2 VPs now. Couldn't you have noticed this earlier?
It's in Options -> View game settings. Well, this is my fault, and I have to apologize - I'll try to fix this, somehow, but I don't think it will really be possible.