[K]

Tuidjy said:
> Overall, Air compares better than Water because:

Only true above water. We were talking underwater, last time I checked.

Yes, we are. And Air magic is still slightly better than Water Magic.

Tuidjy said:
> A. In combat, you are far more likely to encounter cold-resistant or
> cold-immune troops than lightning immune troops. Both are essentially
> single target attack suites, but Air wins handily on this point.

Water strike is not cold based, scales nicely with higher levels, and the damage
is not negligible. I've killed Nycafor in a Cold 3 province with massed
Water strikes. Furthermore, trampling Ice elementals do not care about
cold resistance either. They are lethally brutal against units that do not have
it, and still damn effective otherwise.

But Water Strike is not armor piercing or armor negating, so if you have an Armor or 22 or so you don't even care, so SCs laugh that kind of thing off.

And trampling Ice Elementals are nice, but trampling has it's own weaknesses(Size and Defense). It's a gem-heavy tactic that is good for individual battles but terrible for wars.

Tuidjy said:
> B. Higher level Air battlefield spells win battles. Fog Warriors and Mists of
> Deception have no equal in Water magic.

Fog warriors is not much use against SCs, or cold auras. It is a nice spell to
protect your army, but all you need is to cast it once. And it doesn't do a
thing against the Wolven Winter / Grip of Winter combo.

Mists of Deception is basically cheating in my book. Once it is cast, all you
have to do is retreat the caster to win the battle. Using it in a tactics
argument smacks of desperation.

It's a killer tactic, I agree. If you think it's too good, then play games where it's modded out.

Wolven Winter costs five Water gems. Grip of Winter costs gems. The combo can be easily countered by using cold-immune troops like Wights or Mechanical Men(which are awesome in their own right), or by removing the fatigue by casting Relief, or just winning the battle quickly.

Don't assume a few wins in MP means you have a killer tactic.

Tuidjy said:
> C. Most battle magic for Water requires Cold to be truly effective, so you
> need to burn heavy amounts of Water gems for Wolven Winters or just get
> lucky with a Cold opponent. If you have a Heat opponent, it's a bad day
> for you.

Don't know about you, but I usually make my own cold underwater. Many water
using nations (Seraphs, Giants, LA Atlantis) do not mind cold much. And Wolven
Winter is quite cheap.

And for some reason (would it be because cold does not hurt income underwater?)
many water nations choose Cold 3 for their scales.

Five gems for a three scale drop is not cheap. Assuming a nation has twenty provinces, you are looking at hundreds of gems and dozens of mage turns devoted to chilling things down.

And, just to check, you do know that the Cold-using nations you've mentioned are usually highly Cold resistant, right?

Tuidjy said:
> D. Low level Air magic makes good SCs as well. Mist Form and Mirror Image
> can't be replicated by items, so casters who do Air instead of Water have
> the best of both worlds since the good Water magic can be gained by items.

I far prefer the Rainbow/Hydra Armours and the Boots of the messenger underwater
than the Rime haulberk and the boots of Quickness (undeads are the exception, and
there are other tricks against them). I also know that the 25% of my
Jarls who have Air magic do not bother with it underwater, because I've found
that water and death buffs are more important. Above water, it's a different
story, but once again, no one argues about that.

And anyway, the tactics I have used in all three games, and worked well enough
to win twice and have my opponents prematurely talking about surrendering in the
third is quad-immune SCs fighting under Grip of Winter and Foul Vapors. Above
water, there will also be a lighting storm going on, but hey, no one said I used
only Water magic.

Foul Vapors is a Nature spell. If we want to open up the floor to other ways to kill your SCs, I'd just use Petrify, or Drain Life, or high penetration Enslaves, or any of the dozen other tactics.

You've noted one tactic that works(Neifel Giants with Water magic). For the vast majority of players, that tactic will not work.

Overall, Air magic is sligher stronger underwater for most uses. I'll admit it has no great "kill a lightning-immune SC" tactic other than Mists of Deception or spamming False Horrors until he dies or retreats from Fear or dies from attacker 50-turn kill, but that still doesn't make Water better at troop killing and taking provinces. Heck, with spammed Horrors your Neifel Giant might not even get a chance to cast a single spell (they fly underwater, unlike every other flyer).

I mean, Air has Shimmering Fields. That stuff kills armies with real damage right now and Water has no equivalent.

Fog Warriors at least halves unit losses in every battle it is used. Water has no equivalent.

Tuidjy said:
Your SC is deliberately immune to most low-level Air magic. That heavily
> skews any comparison, so we can't even pretend it's fair.

He is _completely_ immune to both shock and illusion, except for the MoD cheat.
You cannot pull that trick with most Cold Immune SCs, because underwater, Water
magic has tramplers, ice encasing, and physical damage spells.

Yes, a size 6 Tartarian with Air, Earth and Astral magic will be a problem, but
you know, those usually are.

So now he's immune to illusions as well. Let me guess...as soon as I suggest a tactic he is going to mysteriously be immune to that tactic, right?

Ok, fine, I agree. An SC deliberately designed to fight Air magic can't be hurt by Air magic.

So, I guess it's a good thing that there is no nation that gets just Air magic, right? And they have national troops and indie troops and other paths and a host of tactics that can be used.

-------------

That being said, I've said my part: Water is the least effective of the magic paths that are effective underwater. It's not ineffective, which is why I didn't say it was ineffective, but it's last on my list.