I'm going to reply in Mindi's place as she's busy at the moment working on some of the reported issues. Edit: I took so long writing this post that this sentence is no longer true!
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimMorrison
Personally I'm kind of a stickler for not having things "remember me", I don't like leaving my passwords laying around - even on Firefox.
|
I'm pretty sure this was addressed in the main thread we're using for making bug reports. This is one of the things Mindi is looking into.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimMorrison
Anyway Mindi, we know (or we SHOULD know) that you all went through a lot this weekend, and I for one also appreciate all the hard work and attention to detail that was paid. It's obvious that you all want these forums to be attractive AND functional. To not only entice random surfers, but to also properly display the communities that spring up around these games, and the high level of support they tend to receive from their developers.
The problem - and I do think it's ironic that there are so many comments from Dominions players, seeing as it is the highest selling title from Shrapnel, as well as claiming the most active community - is that we are being asked to give up a LOT of functionality and capability, for a lot of control and marketing (for Shrapnel).
|
Yes, that is our goal. I don't agree that it's ironic that the majority of comments are from Dominions players; I think it's to be expected. As you said, the majority of our forum users are Dominions players, so it makes sense that they would make the majority of posts. We also have not yet publicly announced we're open after a three day hiatus, and I think we're seeing the Dominions community return more quickly than some others.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimMorrison
don't think that anyone meant to put anything in a threatening way, but there is wisdom in looking at this from more than a police sort of view. I see so many replies with "this was out of hand", "we don't want that", "people would do this", that remind me of someone cutting off their foot to stop from stubbing their toes.
All leading up to this conversion, many of us were a bit excited, because we kept being told the new software would "allow us to do so much". Currently all I see is that the software allows YOU to do so much - but all the users of the forums get, in trade for all that we are giving up, is slightly larger avatars.
|
Are slightly larger avatars truly the only new feature you see? And that just sort of happened; we don't really see it as an improved feature. With our goal of growing and servicing our tight-knit community in mind, we've added several social networking tools. Some of the new features like the ability to create social groups (added with the multi-player community in mind), post photo albums, and run arcade game tournaments may not be important to some, but we believe they will be enjoyed by others. These are the types of activities people who flock to social networking sites enjoy, and we believe it's a great opportunity to have these types of networking tools within our smaller community where many meaningful relationships already exist.
I'm not sure if you've had a chance to fully explore the expanded options in your user control panel, and I know that some of the functionality there is still being tweaked, but there are many more controllable options for you there than we offered in the previous format. One of my favorite new features is the ability to forward and copy other users within the private messaging system. Maybe I'm alone, but this will make my life easier.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimMorrison
I believe your team is highly underestimating the importance of the Edit issue. I believe you also badly underestimated the PM issue. 300 is still a bit cramped for a really active player, and I think it's a bit silly that the suggested answer is manually archiving what could potentially be 10-15 messages a day.
|
We're not underestimating the importance of the Edit issue at all! Mindi and I have both posted in various places that we've heard some good suggestions and are exploring options for this. Some very valid reasons for needing this feature to be improved have been brought to our attention, and this is a high priority on our list of changes. You won't see a full restore, and you probably won't see a change immediately, but please do understand we are committed to finding a compromise so we have a win/win situation. In the meantime, if anyone needs a post edited, it can be done by contacting a moderator with your request.
I think raising the pm limit to 300 is a good compromise, and we may have to come to agree to disagree on that for the time being. It's the same limit QT3 imposes on it's users, where there are also large communities running multi-player games. I understand it feels stifling to go from absolutely no limit to this, and that's our fault for being so liberal in the past then imposing a limit. The ability to export pm's to a text file, while seen by some as a punishment, is actually an enhancement some users have requested.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JimMorrison
I'm personally in no hurry to go anywhere else - I like it here. But rather than viewing things as threatening, please just have a little break and then look at these issues again. It's not that people are itching for a reason to leave, are ungrateful, or are otherwise unhappy with Shrapnel. But the Dominions community is very active, and very prolific. It's in everyone's best interests if you at Shrapnel continue to provide room for us to do our thing, and if we keep our thrumming hive of activity here, posting links and drawing attention. Just to reiterate - we WANT to stay here, so please reconsider how inhospitable the new forum functions, for our needs. I won't even go into the look of it, I think if it works great, people will tend to get over the rest.
<3
|
And we WANT everyone to stay and be happy. We understand that there are some who are disappointed with the look and disagree with our design decisions. That's to be expected, and we experienced the same reactions when we launched what is now the "old" site. This is a good thread for voicing those opinions. What is truly helpful to us are constructive suggestions for improving functionality, and these should be reported in the stickied thread at the top of this forums.
Thank you for your feedback.