[Edratman]

My incident also involved a SC.

I had two thugs, one with 2 or 3 hearts, and a borderline thug/SC. In the replay the wounded thug dies and the second retreated like a sissy. The SC then rather quickly forces the opposing army (indies) to flee.

Never figured out why I lost.

The battleground province was completely free of troops and my two units just marched in and claimed it subsequent turn.