I also prefer smaller maps. Especially in an RP setting.
I'm also for VP's. It gives the game an end and something RP'ish to fight for. The end might be abrupt, but that doesn't limit the RP/writing joy of the game up to that time.
I consider the writing and RP stuff the most fun part of this kind of game and I will assume that this goes for most people. Thus we are less intent on winning, and more intent on creating interesting stories of a new world
When you have all adopted this doctrine and sit and scribble great literature by candle light I will slaughter you all and claim what is mine!