[rdonj]

I do like the concept, but the others have a point. I think you could probably get away with rating the HoF players without causing too much trouble, but rating everyone is probably a bad idea. And some of these ratings are fairly subjective. A newer player who gets stomped by someone is going to rate that person high, and an older player who stomps someone else is likely to rate them lower. There are people who I know could make reasonable judgements as to how to lay out those scores, but you would probably have to play a number of games with a person to really be a good judge of their dominions personality.

If you got rid of the Dominions Lore, Shrewdness, and Lawful ratings it would be a lot more civil, but that's cutting out a lot of the information you were trying to show.