[WraithLord]

I like your suggestion.

I also agree about the HoF. Not that I really care about this one way or another. For what its worth though, I think that if the intention was to give some statistical measure to a player's strength than at least few additional mandatory numbers should be included.
However, HoF is not what I had in mind, rather something more akin to karma.
I also don't necessarily see drama and discussions as bad things -- so long as they remain polite and positive.