[Loren]

Originally Posted by Poopsi

No it wasn't. I prophetized a Starspawn in my second turn, and then one of my accesory prophets died, and got a chance to reprophetize my prophet. And I did (He's holy 4 atm. And perfectly sane, for the record).

Perhaps it only works once.

Or perhaps it doesnt work unless no commander names itself prophet in the interim.

The latter sounds likely to me.