[TheDemon]

How about these starts? Both teams are in semicircles, the noobs semicircles are bigger, both teams have a very small backfield. Both teams are forced to expand towards the center and towards each other. There's no weakness of a crescent formation, which is bad for the guys on the tips. I understand the less people have a position away from the front the better, but if you leave some space in between the two outer guys, your team should be able to get them to the front with some coordination. If we place all the caps in a semicircle, then you'll have too big of an uncontested area.

All I really did was adjust the starts in Cleveland's version backwards a little. The noob starts near the center appear close together but due to the prov connections they're actually somewhat separated. I included alternate starts in yellow if you want more separation between capitals.