[militarist]

I'm afraid you do not get the idea of this list then, Calahan.
This thread is not about "bad feelings", I expect it not to "encourage flame wars / arguments / hostility between forum members".
But, as for another part of your message, about "branding other members as dishonest / untrustworthy / a cheat " - some trolls troll forums. And there are trolls who troll games, joining them and destroying them from inside, killing all interest and demotivating to join new. And purpose of this thread - is some level of NATURAL control that player community can have to protect itself against these trolls.

I'm absolutely agree that many emotions, blamings, branding as something bad - doesn't add pleasure. But pleasure should not be based on illusions. Because if it's based on illusions, at the end of the day you will have disillusion, and it will lead to much worse emotions then those you are talking here about.