[llamabeast]

I think it's great that everyone has posted here to say this isn't a good idea - I agree that it really isn't a good idea. Thinking along the same lines as Edi, I won't lock it now, in case there is more useful debate to be had. But such a list is never going to work well.

militarist, I think it would be great if you removed the names of the two players from the first post, since it is clear that there are at least two sides to the story and having them there is quite harsh.