[Q]

Geoschmo I can't reproduce your findings.
I fleeted ships with anti proton beams and ships with only planetary napalm as weapons. Strategy for all ships and the fleet standard optimal firing range/optimal weapons range. Whether I select "ships break formation" or not, the ships with the planetary napalm will attack the planet exactely the same as the ships with the anti proton beams.
Any idea what could be the difference?