[DRG]

Could be...129 points for doing nothing is suspicious.... the issue is that 129 points the Germans get does not correspond to anything that happened in the previous scenario. There was no combat in your switch scenario and neither side took casualties

Do you have a save just before the switch scenario you can use then make a simple change to the switch scenario and see if the result changes?

Also, if you switch both ways do the Germans get 129 phantom points both ways ?

Does this switch scenario have only one V hex and did you pile all 21 into that one hex? It's been a while since I placed scenario V hexes but a common error is one left in the top left corner but you've done this many times so it's unlikely but the German side has been given 129 points and the 129 is even more suspicious because it's such an odd number

If you have a pre switch save try the switch again, do the same thing and see if the result is the same each time. If it does not change then try changing the switch scenario in some way then try again

The issue I have with this is if phantom points given to the AI in a campaign was common I would have expected to hear about it more than once in 2 decades