[Slynky]

Originally posted by geoschmo:
1. Losing a single game send you to the bottom of the hill. A bit harsh? Certainly no fun.

2. Only works for two player games. Not everybody likes two player games. Not everybody does well at two player games.

3. You are in many ways at the mercy of your opponent. If you are playing a guy that is slow with the turns, what can you do? Not much. Complain to me, that's about it. If you and your opponent can't agree on settings, you can't just go play someone else who does like your sort of game. You have to play who I match you against, or one of you forfeits. That kind of sucks.

4. The league page is tedious to maintain, and therefore is frequently out of date. Mea Culpa.

5. You can't play more than one official game at a time. Some people don't like that I am sure.

Geoschmo

1. Seems a bit harsh...and doesn't reflect the game we played as a child...'cause if you were trying for the top of the hill, you didn't always fall back to the bottom. Not sure how to change it, though.

2. Yeah, but 2-player reflects one against one. And not 2 against 1. Or something uneven like that. It's bad enough to get a bad position (system-wise, etc.) without throwing in additional things which may thwart what might be excellent play by an individual. Also, can't quite figure out why someone would be bad at 2-player. Does that mean they only do good when they have diplomacy at their disposal? Which may lead to what I was talking about at the beginning of this me item.

3. Yeah, I'm not sure what to suggest for that. Perhaps the name could be shown in the grid (or ladder) with a number that reflects the hourly limit they will commit to with regularity. Then people could be paired according to that number (or as near as possible).

4. OBE, we say in our office... Surely there must be another enterprising individual with the requisite skills to provide you some relief. This would me access to the server (gulp) or someone who could also provide the bandwidth.

5. Not sure what this one means. If you mean more than one KOTH game at once, I wouldn't think that would work. So....

Anyway, my two-cents worth. (BTW, I just petitioned to join KOTH).