Re: [OT] Nerds
I don't' think Puke was referring to the essay that started the thread, but rather to the author of the materiel that Puke linked.
I did say I like this essay, and I do, but I have found a contradiction.
The author says that kids are put in school because they are useless to the modern world. This is believable, in fact I like it.
He says they are useless to the modern world because the specialized modern world requires years more of training before its workers are of any use. Sounds nice.
But then he also says, many times, that there is no point to schooling, and that it accomplishes nothing. I am somewhat inclined to agree with this but...
This would seem to indicate that kids are being kept out of the workforce so that they can receive training that they are not receiving. While this may be the case, it is a contradiction of reason that the author does not bring to light. I am mildly disappointed.
But I do find great 'personal truth' in the essay nonetheless.
I would also like to point out that I am a great supporter of public school for a number of reasons. One worth mentioning is that I have met many, many products of the homeschool system, but I have yet to meet one that qualifies as 'adjusted'. The best I found was one who seemed okay for about a week. And he beat out the runner-up but about thirteen days, eighteen hours. He also turned out to be incapable of real communication (though he was a damn good mimic, best job I've seen done by a man).
If you're homeschooled and you think you're adjusted, don't take this personally. It doesn't apply to you, I have met you. Relax.
|
Threaded Mode