Random Magic Paths - is it truly random?

[Taqwus]

No.

Think about it: it's actually impossible for the total allocation of the three most-picked paths to be anything less than 3/8. If it were, at least one of those three paths would necessarily be underrepresented (below 1/8) and at least one of the five "rarer" paths must be overrepresented (above 1/8), which is a contradiction because then they wouldn't be the three most-picked paths.