Graeme you neglected that both cast quickness and watershield which both increase defense .
So both have to fight against a 10-15 higher def with their attack Ratings but the ice devil has 5 def more than the waterqueen .
I just posted so vague numbers because i don't remember exactly how many points extradef you get from quickness and from watershield .
I am tired today ( it is 3 a.m. here
) but tomorrow i will make a quicktest to get the correct numbers for watershield + quickness def and then i post it with statistics .
If you remember them already plz be so kind and post them