[OT] Plato's Pub and Philosophical Society

[tbontob]

Originally posted by Kamog:
Some people say that only humans are self-aware and animals are not. According to them, a dog is not capable of introspection - it is able to learn and react to situations, but it does not know that it is doing so. I think that there is no way to confirm if this is true or not. Intuitively, it does not seem right that humans are special and fundamentally different from other life forms.

If humans have free will, then do dogs have free will? How about fish? Insects? Bacteria? Where do we draw the line? In my opinion, if we say that humans have free will, then all life forms must have it also.

If it is possible to arrange a collection of atoms in such a way as to have free will (as in a human brain), then in theory it must also be possible to construct a machine that has free will.

I agree with you Kamog.

We humans often make the mistake of defining attributes in human terms.

It is obvious that animals do not have our self-awareness.

Now, it could be a matter of degree or they may have a self-awareness which is fundamentally different from ours.

So, just because they do not share our "type" of self-awareness, does not mean they lack self-awareness.

The above comments also apply to the concept of free will.