OT - How would sc-fi ships do in battle against each other?

[Rojero]

Originally posted by narf poit chez BOOM:


any and all sci-fi ships welcome. please be aware, though, that there really isn't much point in bringing, say, a fully completed death star into it, since we all know they fall like flies to fighter's and corvettes but blow up everything else. unless you bring in a DW planatiod.

this is an invitation to discussion, not a retry at my battle thread.

How about that doomsday device from the original star trek series that kirk had to fight with commodore decker? you think that the death star can take it out? or will it get eaten by the "giant ice cream cone"?