A question on Atlantis

[Karacan]

Cohen said:
Underwater Voice of Tiamat rules. You start to gain some income for casting all other site searching spell on surface except death and blood ... but you can always alchemize your astral pearls (clam clam).

Voice Of Tiamat finds all Elemental sites. That means no blood, death, astral, nature, holy and unholy. The most interesting underwatersites are astral, so it's imperative that you add an astralsitesearching spell to your mages' duties.



That said, I certainly don't share the conviction of some selfdeclared experts that Atlantis is weak. Watermagic leaves a bit to be desired in terms of summons and impressive combatmagic, but the nation itself works very well. Frozen Heart is a great spell, especially against small Groups of elite soldiers, or not frost-immune SCs.

[Boron]

Karacan said:

That said, I certainly don't share the conviction of some selfdeclared experts that Atlantis is weak. Watermagic leaves a bit to be desired in terms of summons and impressive combatmagic, but the nation itself works very well. Frozen Heart is a great spell, especially against small Groups of elite soldiers, or not frost-immune SCs.

lol i never said i am an expert rofl

mid-lategame with your mentioned tactics + clamhoarding atlantis may be not so bad sure .
but all undeads are cold immune ! so if you don't have lots of priests what i doubt because they are rather expensive ermor can be too hard if it borders the see and decides to wipe you out earlygame .

your other earlygame enemy ryleh is hard too .

finally midgame a attack with a few fully euqipped scs , especially ice devils can give you hard trouble too .
you can't summon banelords in the sea .
your water queens are inferior to ice devils .
getting a foothold on the continent + defending it is extremely hard as atlantis .
summonable scs in the sea are only afaik :
- wraith lords
- water queens
- in theory : the ice devils


most maps just support 1 underwater nation and most ppl chose then ryleh because most think it is a bit better than atlantis .

[archaeolept]

your water queens are inferior to ice devils .

:O

summonable scs in the sea are only afaik :
- wraith lords
- water queens
- in theory : the ice devils

kings of elemental earth, eater of the dead, perhaps half the tartarians if you really had no land...

[Graeme Dice]

Boron said:
but all undeads are cold immune ! so if you don't have lots of priests what i doubt because they are rather expensive ermor can be too hard if it borders the see and decides to wipe you out earlygame .

Coral Queens cost about the same as C'Tis Priest Kings. Consorts are very physically tough and cost the same as battle deacons.

your other earlygame enemy ryleh is hard too .

They aren't that hard for Atlantis. Your troops are superior to theirs, and you have access to friendly currents right off the bat. Illithid's are archers, and you have access to flying troops as soon as you conquer your first province.

finally midgame a attack with a few fully euqipped scs , especially ice devils can give you hard trouble too .
you can't summon banelords in the sea .
your water queens are inferior to ice devils .

What? Water queens are completely superior to ice devils, and would give air queens an easy run for their money. It's nothing to sneeze at when you can regenerate 40 or more hitpoints per turn on a unit with inherent water magic and 0 base encumbrance.

most maps just support 1 underwater nation and most ppl chose then ryleh because most think it is a bit better than atlantis .

That might have been true before the duration of Illithid paralysis was reduced to its current levels. Now, it's not too hard to overwhelm them with sufficient numbers. Try a water 6 Nerid with order 3, prod 3, misfortune 2, magic 3, kelp citadel. Or create yourself a nice meat shield out of the ancient Kraken to absorb Triton attacks.

[Boron]

Graeme Dice said:

What? Water queens are completely superior to ice devils, and would give air queens an easy run for their money. It's nothing to sneeze at when you can regenerate 40 or more hitpoints per turn on a unit with inherent water magic and 0 base encumbrance.

The best ice devil statwise , Bune has 16 att and 20 def .
The water queens have 15 att/def .

Both have watermagic so both can cast water shield and quickness .

The ice devil can easy take either bloodthorn + lucky coin shield or wraith sword .

All in all the final result is that the ice devil has about 5 more def and something like def 25-30 in total while the water queen has about 20-25 def in total and the ice devil has even 1 higher base attack .
So the water queen hits with odds like < 1% while the ice devil has a first hit chance of like 3-5% .

With the bloodthorn/wraithsword he slowly fatigues the water queen which reduces def . So the waterqueen will fatigue out normally sometime and die then .

You can of course take reinvigoration items but the ice devil has already 1 slot advantage : the foot slot .
If you want to take a reinvigoration item with your waterqueen the ice devil has even 2 slots advantage then .

A waterqueen just almost can't hit a correct equipped icedevil while she gets hit occasionally which is enough for the ice devil to win . So the ice devil should win about 990 of 1000 fights against a water queen .

The ice devil though is probably the only Nonpretendersc which beats a waterqueen Sc underwater .

[Graeme Dice]

Boron said:
The best ice devil statwise , Bune has 16 att and 20 def .
The water queens have 15 att/def .

The ice devil can easy take either bloodthorn + lucky coin shield or wraith sword .

So can the water queen. There's no difference in the equipment this way.

So the water queen hits with odds like < 1% while the ice devil has a first hit chance of like 3-5% .

If you're going to make your argument solely on theory and statistics, then you should really make sure that you get those statistics correct. A 5 point difference between attack and defense means that the water queen will hit 14% of the time, assuming that you haven't outfitted her for increased attack and defense.

With the bloodthorn/wraithsword he slowly fatigues the water queen which reduces def . So the waterqueen will fatigue out normally sometime and die then .

The water queen has a base encumbrance of 0. Life drain should not increase her fatigue at all. If it does, then she'll be able to recover it all back everytime that she does hit the ice devil. After all, her attacks cost her no fatigue.

You can of course take reinvigoration items but the ice devil has already 1 slot advantage : the foot slot .

Which will likely be taken by flying boots, which do nothing underwater. There is no other boot that would be of any particular benefit in this combat.

A waterqueen just almost can't hit a correct equipped icedevil while she gets hit occasionally which is enough for the ice devil to win . So the ice devil should win about 990 of 1000 fights against a water queen.

You might want to not use invalid numbers to support your purely theoretical arguments that go against what you'd actually see in the game.

The ice devil though is probably the only Nonpretendersc which beats a waterqueen Sc underwater .

It won't beat one underwater.

[Boron]

Graeme you neglected that both cast quickness and watershield which both increase defense .

So both have to fight against a 10-15 higher def with their attack Ratings but the ice devil has 5 def more than the waterqueen .

I just posted so vague numbers because i don't remember exactly how many points extradef you get from quickness and from watershield .

I am tired today ( it is 3 a.m. here ) but tomorrow i will make a quicktest to get the correct numbers for watershield + quickness def and then i post it with statistics .
If you remember them already plz be so kind and post them

[Yossar]

Are you forgetting that Water Queens regenerate 90% of their hps per round? That and the ability to equip a herald lance for triple damage against the demonic ice devil is a huge advantage.

[tka]

Boron said:
Graeme you neglected that both cast quickness and watershield which both increase defense .

So both have to fight against a 10-15 higher def with their attack Ratings but the ice devil has 5 def more than the waterqueen .

I just posted so vague numbers because i don't remember exactly how many points extradef you get from quickness and from watershield .

...

Quickness gives +3 def and Water Shield +5.

Ice Devil suffers -3 to Attack and Defence and it also suffers +3 penalty to Encumbrance when fighting underwater.

Equiped Water Queen beats equally equiped ID without any problems.

[Boron]

So you were right (again) graeme but at least it was a good learning experience for me (again)

Why didn't you mention yourself the water penalty though ?


Now i ask the other way round : Which Sc can beat a waterqueen underwater ?
None ?