OT: Superman and Stemcells

[johan osterman]

Arryn I am not sure what you mean by Subscribe to logic. But I imagine that one would not have any great difficulty digging up any number counter examples amongst logicians or mathematicians guilty of one or more of the 'sins' you list. I think you attribute a broader normative use to logic than what is warranted. And to be blunt, I think you confuse your own attitudes with logic.