tholians

[oleg]

After reading the stormy discussion about Gorn ship set, I believe my Tholians insulted quite a few trekkies. Therefore I am inclined to make them some other race and never ever again touch anything ST related. Please vote what should I do: keep them or change ?

[Q]

This is just my very humble personal opinion, but I find this critic about the authenticity of races inappropriate. If you don't like the race, nobody forces you to use it. And I believe the creators of the races should have the freedom to make it like they want it to be and not be slaves to the original TV pictures.

[geoschmo]

Originally posted by oleg:
After reading the stormy discussion about Gorn ship set, I believe my Tholians insulted quite a few trekkies. Therefore I am inclined to make them some other race and never ever again touch anything ST related. Please vote what should I do: keep them or change ?

Don't take it too seriously Oleg. All this stuff is made up anyway. The Tholians and Gorn are two extremely MONOR races form TOS. The Tholians had one ship, and IIRC we never even got to seeee the Gorn ships even once. So everything else since, ie Star Fleet Battles is just something someone else made up anyway. It just so happens they made it up before you did. That doesn't make it any more correct than yours.

Besides, who says we can't have more than one of these shipsets floating around. There are 5 or 6 Federation shipsets by my count. Noone is claiming theirs to be "official".

So, don't take the critics too seriously. Have fun making your shipsets. And know that they will be used and appreciated by somebody, that's what counts right?

Geoschmo

[Captain Kwok]

Oleg:

I actually thought your shipset represented the Tholians quite well. The translucent colouring and faceted look are exactly what I would expect from them. Don't get discouraged by a few minor complaints/whines - it's what Star Trek fans do best.

[Pax]

Originally posted by oleg:
After reading the stormy discussion about Gorn ship set, I believe my Tholians insulted quite a few trekkies. Therefore I am inclined to make them some other race and never ever again touch anything ST related. Please vote what should I do: keep them or change ?

Nonono ... don't give up on ST races. You don't have to change your shipset either.

That's not the sort of response I wanted to provoke in folks who make shipsets; with you, you evenmentioned some SFB details (the use of multiple smaller hulls to make larger ships), and Iw anted to point you at further resoruces for future refinements ... along the lines you'd already chosen for the set, and/or if you wanted to evolve the set closer to an SFB look.

They don't say "Tholian" to me, but it's still a good shipset, and there're plenty of Trekkers out there who're less of a purist than I am WRT how such and such a ship type might look.

And oleg ... I'm a FANATICAL Tholian fan. We're talking, foaming at the mouth rabid fancritter where the Tholians are concerned (gotta love the Neotholian's Webcaster ... *drool*).

And your ships don't insult me. Fall short of what I might have created n yoru place? Well hell, man, anythign that wasn't 100% accurate to SFB would do that ... if it was off by one pixel!

Keep the ships. Maybe make a future revision that uses some of the SFB resources I pointed you to (I'd like that, of course!). But don't toss 'em in the recycle bin just because one extremely vocal member of the comunity spoke up about his dissatisfaction with current shipsets based on established SF races ...

Please!

[Fyron]

SFB isn't canon, so ships don't have to look like what SFB ships look like.

[Baron Munchausen]

Originally posted by oleg:
After reading the stormy discussion about Gorn ship set, I believe my Tholians insulted quite a few trekkies. Therefore I am inclined to make them some other race and never ever again touch anything ST related. Please vote what should I do: keep them or change ?

It's a nice shipset. Keep it. If you are concerned about 'authenticity' then make another set based on the SFB images. You could call the SFB based set Tholians and call your first set something else, and give them a backstory about being the race from another galaxy come to get the Tholians!

Apparently the 'backstory' for the Tholians is that they are refugees from another galaxy where they had an empire and enslaved other races. When the plebes rebelled and started to slaughter the rulers, some of them gathered up some ships and fled. And arrived here.