Planet Capture? Is it worth it?

[Atrocities]

I don't know how many of you are Rebellion fans, (Star Wars Rebellion) but I would hope that many of you are.

In Rebellion, it was a pivital part of the game to CAPTURE planets. Either by diplomacy, or by direct force.

The one thing I have noticed in SEIV is that capturing a planet can become a very difficult thing to do. In my opinion, one that does not warrent the needed aggervation it takes to acheive. Even though capturing a planet my be advantagous to your efforts, the cost of actually capturing the planet, in the time it takes to do so, is far more expensive than it would be to wipe it out and recolonize it.

So, is capturing a planet a viable option in SEIV? Or is it just a waste of time? At first, I thought it was important, but now, I feel that it is just a waste of time.

------------------
"We've made too many compromises already, too many retreats! They invade our space and we fall back -- they assimilate entire worlds and we fall back! Not again! The line must be drawn here -- this far, no further! And I will make them pay for what they've done!" -- Patric Stewart as Captain Picard
UCP/TCO Ship Yards

[Puke]

BAH! of course it is. its not viable right off, since it takes some time to research troops and get effective weapons on them.

however once you can put men on the ground, it is very valueable.

now dont get me wrong, capturing small colonies with under 20M and about 2 facilities is DUMB. homewolds on the other hand:

Give you a base of population to put on like-atmosphere planets. give you the production bonus from the higher initial population. and the facilities. lets say you recolonize it and have to rebuild all the facilities, it costs you resources for about 2-5 years while you build your 20 or so facilities back with your low initial population, then you can start doing things with the planet. On the other hand, not only do you not have to spend those resources and population rebuilding the planet (if you have people for the right atmosphere type even), but you GET all of the resource / research production from the planet AND you can use it to build other things.

definitly worth it. there is a cutover point though, i probably would not bother for less than about 75M and 10 facilities, unless I was hard pressed for a spaceyard that they had.

[SirDarwin]

Peronsally I think it would be more worth it if the AI were a little more intelligent for decieding what colonists to move to what planets. Its no fun when the AI mixes population, or uses the wrong type.

[Tomgs]

If the AI gets to the point that it makes wise decisions with its assorted colonists then it may come and conquer a few of our worlds. The added resources and capacity this would give it would definately be a good step in the right direction. Now if we could get it to make neutrals surrender to them so they could get easy colonization tech like we can that would be great.

I would like to recieve a message from the AI one day that says: You dared to attack the Phong don't you know that they are subjugated to the great Terran Empire and we will burn your worlds for attacking them.

[SirDarwin]

quote:

---

Originally posted by Tomgs:
I would like to recieve a message from the AI one day that says: You dared to attack the Phong don't you know that they are subjugated to the great Terran Empire and we will burn your worlds for attacking them.

---

That would just be awesome I really think that when the diplomacy/interaction with the AI gets better this will truly be a awesome game. Right now its a good military game, with the awesome ability to modify. Just no feeling to it

[Tomgs]

Well after I posted the below I read the beta patch thread and read this:

30. Fixed - Improved the Transport Minister so that they only move populations to
planets with atmospheres they can breathe.

So that seems to be improved anyway.