Questions

[Viking John]

Hello

1. I have noticed that my helicopters will cover each other , when one is moving and takes fire from a spotted enemy or even if the enemy just changes its facing to face the moving helicopter the other ones around will fire at enemy unit. My Question is Why don't the Infantry and vehicals do the same thing ?

2. I have had CD version since ,, well lets just say I remember when having enginers allowed you to place mines and dig in your troops during game . I have really never used the over watch setting much , and never seen any thing happen when I did . Question is Does anyone use it and what does it really do ( how it works )

I have lots of questions , but lets start with these

[Mobhack]

1) Ground units do react - e.g. to a failed close assault. Tanks will beat up on infantry revealing themselves. Cant say I have seen helos popping off at random though.

2) Engineers have never dug in your troops or laid mines in these games. You are likely thinking about another game developed by different folks?.

2.1) The overwatch feature is sometimes useful if you only want to fire at say the exit from a town. Place the hex where the road exits, set the distance to a small circle, and then ensure you reduce the regular opfire distance for the overwatching unit!. The overwatched circle must be outside the main opfire range measured round the firer to be useful. Otherwise the primary opfire circle will naturally take precedence.

[Viking John]

1. when I play us vs VC ,, my helicopters will fire at enemy troops who shoot at moving Helo's , but when I am moving my infantry up and enemy unit fires at them none of their platton units shoot back even though they are in range and have a line of sight , I have to take control of the units and do it myself. I like the way the helo's respond to cover each other without me having to do it


It was either MBT or WW2 one In fact I think it was the WW2 I bought both CD versions at same time but had the WW2 one free for awhile to test it and played that one more,, I remember opening the unit window and clicking on place mines for enginers ,, only other game I ever had like this was the original SSI Steel Panthers , well computer game like this I played the Avolon Hill game Squad leader game back in mid 70's.

I sort of remember the reason it was changed was because of the limited time, really wasn't realistic to allow for mines to be placed 2 min per turn ,, back then most games where under 30 turns even when playing random campaign.

[Viking John]

I thought setting over watch hex would let your unit fire at any enemy inside that area that shoots at your moving troops ,, is that not the reason for a over watch to cover and suppress enemy while some of your units advance ? If it worked like that it would be real useful to set up units on over watch.

[Mobhack]

Originally Posted by Viking John

I thought setting over watch hex would let your unit fire at any enemy inside that area that shoots at your moving troops ,, is that not the reason for a over watch to cover and suppress enemy while some of your units advance ? If it worked like that it would be real useful to set up units on over watch.

It is just an area that the normal reaction fire to enemy movement or firing happens in, that you can place outside the normal circle round your unit.

So select the hex and the radius round it at some point of interest, and set the normal opfire circle round the firing unit smaller.

It has its uses, mainly for scenario designers I would think (for setting up ambushes). I may have used it in normal game play once in a year or so.

[DRG]

Originally Posted by Viking John

It was either MBT or WW2 one In fact I think it was the WW2 I bought both CD versions at same time but had the WW2 one free for awhile to test it and played that one more,, I remember opening the unit window and clicking on place mines for enginers ,, only other game I ever had like this was the original SSI Steel Panthers , well computer game like this I played the Avolon Hill game Squad leader game back in mid 70's.

I sort of remember the reason it was changed was because of the limited time, really wasn't realistic to allow for mines to be placed 2 min per turn ,, back then most games where under 30 turns even when playing random campaign.

As Andy said, we have NEVER allowed engineers to place mines for all the reasons you mentioned

[shahadi]

Originally Posted by Viking John

1. when I play us vs VC ,, my helicopters will fire at enemy troops who shoot at moving Helo's , but when I am moving my infantry up and enemy unit fires at them none of their platton units shoot back even though they are in range and have a line of sight , I have to take control of the units and do it myself. I like the way the helo's respond to cover each other without me having to do it

I don't see the answer to Viking John's question here. If this feature is implemented in the current game, how is it turned on?

=====

[DRG]

You have full control of your infantry during your move. If we did it any other way we'd get complaints your units were firing at targets you didn't choose to fire at.....but we get complaints no matter what we do.

Heleo will, on occasion, provide covering fire for another helo and it's been that way AFAIK, for years. So it's not a " feature" you turn on an off. It's the way it's coded..be happy they do that

[shahadi]

Oh, I like the helo cover fire. Great feature.

If we had a poll, I'd put my john henry down for squads covering each other by platoon (in the game, squads within a formation). Infantry.

=====

[Viking John]

Originally Posted by DRG

You have full control of your infantry during your move. If we did it any other way we'd get complaints your units were firing at targets you didn't choose to fire at.....but we get complaints no matter what we do.

Heleo will, on occasion, provide covering fire for another helo and it's been that way AFAIK, for years. So it's not a " feature" you turn on an off. It's the way it's coded..be happy they do that

If they only fired Op fire during over watch during your turn , we would still have control because we are the ones that set the over watch and set filters ,, This would be make the over watch filter useful more then once a year or just for scinerio designers ...... and it would still work like it does now limiting the firing unit to just what is targeted.


I will make wish list , and only put one idea per thread. Sometimes when putting a few in same thread all attention gets put on one thing and the others are ignored or forgotten about. maybe we can get the fourms more active and get others offing ideas and talking about them even if they will never be done. having active fourms when people come to check out the game is better then them coming and thinking this game is dead because no one is on fourms and then don't give it a try.


P.S. I was wrong back when I first looked at this game I had also checked out Steel Panthers WaW free version , befor I bought this one , they are the ones that had the features where Enginers layed mines and you could set some of your troops under AI control using Advance and defend stance on unit Info screen.