I am playing (and hosting) a PBEM game myself (with simultaneous turns). We started with 11 players, who are by now (turn 93 or so) whittled down to eight, mostly due to dropouts for personal reasons or due to close proximity to a more powerful neighbour...
We do a turn per day (so if you count back you can see we started this shortly after release of SE4).
Compared to Stars! it takes about the same time, except for the bit hosting business, like Aussie Gamer described it. Something like the Stars! Autohost would sure be nice, but doing this by hand is not too much trouble.
BTW, seems I have the same crowd in my game, Possum! Both Yan and Ferendra are still active in my game.
To Raynor: Yes, you can generate a turn even without files from the players. In that case the AI steps in for the missing ones. In my experience about every other day or so one player or the other seems to be unable to send his orders, so this feature is needed.
As I see it PBEM is the best way to play such games, because playing a turn at an advanced state of the game takes far too long for LAN gaming or such. Of course you need to plan for a duration of six months or so to finish a game...
