|  | 
| 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
    
    
 |  | 
 
 
	
		|  |  
	
	
		
	
	
	| 
			
			 
			
				January 7th, 2007, 12:36 PM
			
			
			
		 |  
	| 
		
			|  | 
 Major General |  | 
					Join Date: Sep 2006 
						Posts: 2,198
					 Thanks: 90 
		
			
				Thanked 32 Times in 22 Posts
			
		
	      |  |  
    
	| 
				 Quick question on movement 
 A large army is in a castle province with move orders to a neighbouring enemy province. 
Forces teleport in to engage the army.
 
What happens?
 
1) Will the entire army fight the teleporting army in the magic battles phase of the turn? 
Or 
2) Will the army stay behind the castles walls.  Leaving a battle between the teleporters vs PD and patrollers. 
OR 
3) As no. 2 but the army trys to carry out as much of the move order as possible and attacks the teleporters in the normal movement battles phase, assuming the teleporters defeated the PD/patrollers.
 
Help, brain hurts, can not compute, danger of overload...   |  
	
		
	
	
	| 
			
			 
			
				January 7th, 2007, 02:41 PM
			
			
			
		 |  
	| 
		
			|  | 
 National Security Advisor |  | 
					Join Date: Oct 2003 Location: Helsinki, Finland 
						Posts: 5,425
					 Thanks: 174 
		
			
				Thanked 695 Times in 267 Posts
			
		
	      |  |  
    
	| 
				 Re: Quick question on movement 
 I don't know for certain. 
I think the most likely things is that the army will stay inside the walls, leaving the PD alone. In the movement phase, it will either move away or not, depending among other things on the phases of the moon.
 
There are some really strange things that can happen with the magic, movement and event phases. One of the more curious things I've seen happen is that I get a barbarian horde event in a province that has Niefeflheim's turmoil 3, sloth 3, death 3, misoftune 3 dominion and on the same turn Niefelheim puts my castle there under siege. Nothing in particular happens. The next turn I kick his pitiful forces out of the province. And right after the siege breaking battle, the barbarian horde from the turn before attacks me (and dies, of course).
 
The question for all and sundry: WTF, and who is responsible?!    
Edi |  
	
		
	
	
	| 
			
			 
			
				January 7th, 2007, 02:54 PM
			
			
			
		 |  
	| 
		
			|  | 
 Captain |  | 
					Join Date: Sep 2004 Location: France 
						Posts: 961
					 Thanks: 2 
		
			
				Thanked 12 Times in 8 Posts
			
		
	      |  |  
    
	| 
				 Re: Quick question on movement 
 I think 2, probably not 3, perhaps 4 ("the teleporters control the castle province but the army move").
 (iirc I've tried to intercept one of your armies in 300mp some turns ago, taking a province between your starting position and your destination in magical phase, but your army managed to reach the destination anyway - but I may be wrong if you had another army I couldn't see with same kind of troops).
 |  
	
		
	
	
	| 
			
			 
			
				January 7th, 2007, 06:01 PM
			
			
			
		 |  
	| 
		
			|  | 
 Major General |  | 
					Join Date: Sep 2006 
						Posts: 2,198
					 Thanks: 90 
		
			
				Thanked 32 Times in 22 Posts
			
		
	      |  |  
    
	| 
				 Re: Quick question on movement 
 Thanks for the replies, I will give what I had in mind a go.  Then tell you all the answer myself after the next turn hopefully. 
If its a diaster I'll blame Edi.   |  
	
		
	
	
	| 
			
			 
			
				January 7th, 2007, 06:10 PM
			
			
			
		 |  
	| 
		
			|  | 
 First Lieutenant |  | 
					Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Palo Alto, CA 
						Posts: 638
					 Thanks: 1 
		
			
				Thanked 3 Times in 3 Posts
			
		
	      |  |  
    
	| 
				 Re: Quick question on movement 
 I think scenario number 1 will happen. |  
	
		
	
	
	| 
			
			 
			
				January 7th, 2007, 08:10 PM
			
			
			
		 |  
	| 
		
			|  | 
 Captain |  | 
					Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: Rhode Island 
						Posts: 822
					 Thanks: 0 
		
			
				Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
			
		
	      |  |  
    
	| 
				 Re: Quick question on movement 
 Heck, my guess would be 3. Try it and report back.   
I'm playing Late Atlantis right now, and having fun playing with the possibilities achievable with flying, sailing, amphibious commanders... |  
	
		
	
	
	| 
			
			 
			
				January 8th, 2007, 12:07 PM
			
			
			
		 |  
	| 
		
			
			| 
 Second Lieutenant |  | 
					Join Date: Dec 2003 
						Posts: 404
					 Thanks: 0 
		
			Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
		
	      |  |  
    
	| 
				 Re: Quick question on movement 
 
	Quote: 
	
		| Edi said: The next turn I kick his pitiful forces out of the province. And right after the siege breaking battle, the barbarian horde from the turn before attacks me (and dies, of course).
 
 |  Independent invaders always wait politely untill the siege is over before they attack, however many turns it takes. It's probably an old bug. |  
	
		
	
	
	| 
			
			 
			
				January 7th, 2007, 11:24 PM
			
			
			
		 |  
	| 
		
			|  | 
 Major General |  | 
					Join Date: Sep 2006 
						Posts: 2,198
					 Thanks: 90 
		
			
				Thanked 32 Times in 22 Posts
			
		
	      |  |  
    
	| 
				 Re: Quick question on movement 
 
	Quote: 
	
		| Meglobob said: A large army is in a castle province with move orders to a neighbouring enemy province.
 
 Forces teleport in to engage the army.
 
 What happens?
 
 1) Will the entire army fight the teleporting army in the magic battles phase of the turn?
 Or
 2) Will the army stay behind the castles walls.  Leaving a battle between the teleporters vs PD and patrollers.
 OR
 3) As no. 2 but the army trys to carry out as much of the move order as possible and attacks the teleporters in the normal movement battles phase, assuming the teleporters defeated the PD/patrollers.
 
 Help, brain hurts, can not compute, danger of overload...
   
 |  Turned out to be none of the above.    
Twan was spot on.
 
It was 4)  My teleporters captured the province, then waved the 400+ enemy troops on there way to a safe neighbouring province.
 
Unless all castles in dominions have a back door, this is a movement bug. |  
	
		
	
	
	
	
	
	
	| 
	|  Posting Rules |  
	| 
		
		You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts 
 HTML code is On 
 |  |  |  |  |